Rajeev Syal
Win a year of free pizza at PizzaExpress
Western governments and aid agencies offering to send teams of rescue workers to China were rebuffed yesterday by a senior Chinese official.
The head of China’s Civil Affairs Ministry said that foreigners would not be allowed in to the country because travel conditions were too difficult in the Sichuan region.
Wang Zhenyao, the head of the Ministry’s Relief Department told a press conference: “Transportation in affected areas is obstructed and it is impossible for our rescue teams to reach the disaster-hit areas. So the conditions are not yet ripe for us to allow international rescue teams into China.”
One senior aid worker said anonymously that the Chinese Government should allow foreign rescue teams in while there was still hope of finding buried victims alive. “This is distinctly unhelpful. There are basic jobs that could be done such as locating those who are still alive, but the Government is holding us back,” he said.
Mr Wang’s comments echo those of Burmese leaders, who have declined to allow foreign aid workers into the country since last week’s typhoon.
China has accepted foreign aid in the past for disasters such as the typhoons and floods that often tear through parts of the south and centre during the summer. However, it does not usually welcome foreign aid workers, preferring to rely on its home-grown skills. People’s Liberation Army troops and the paramilitary armed police have decades of experience of coping with disasters.
Rain in the coming days in Sichuan is expected to hamper earthquake relief efforts, as well as increase risks of landslides, the China Meteorological Administration said.
The United States plans to contribute $500,000 (£256,000) to help with earthquake relief efforts in anticipation of an appeal for aid by the International Red Cross, the White House said yesterday. The Hong Kong Government will donate US$38 million to Beijing to help with rescue efforts.
David Miliband, the Foreign Secretary, praised the Chinese authorities for their “exemplary” response to the devastating earthquake.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2008
£44,990
2008
£48,489
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
Circa £100k
NHS
London
£23,500 + benefits
MI5
London
Some of the finest Apts & Penthouses
Across London
Great Investment, River Views
Luxury properties within exclusive development in
Chislehurst Kent
A new experience in Luxury Living
Multi–Centre
from Only £829pp
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - search houses for sale and rooms and property to rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
if you cann't even reach the disaster-hit areas,how can you do the basic jobs to help victims? Anyone whoever have visited sichuan knows how terrible the travel conditions is there .China government cares not only for chinese victims,but also for all the helpers!
helen, fuzhou, china
Jingjing, do you really think the survivors will care if the person who finds them speaks Chinese or not? They will be grateful to be alive! The foreign teams have equipment and skills designed for these exact situations, the Chinese only have lots and lots of people.
Gaz, Wuhan, China
The reason they let in the other asian and russian teams is because China has launched an offensive against the big bad west in recent months, they cant lose face by allowing the big bad west to help them and perhaps make some Chinese question what they have been lead to believe on CCTV.
Gaz, Wuhan, China
I think language is the most significant barrier to stop foreign rescuers'access.It's much better to provide material supply and technical support instead of sending rescuers
Jingjing, Guangzhou, China
Rescue teams from Japan,HongKong and TaiWan are gathering in Beijing and ready to start out soon.They are not allowed to into Sichuan in early days just because of safefy problems.The Chinese goverment is doing the best to save lives.Premier Wen is really great and worth the highest respect!
wangyun, Beijing, China
Kun Huo, your donation can get to work immediately. The Chinese Red Cross Society is coordinating relief efforts. I have witnessed thousands of volunteers working very hard in the city to collect, sort, repack and ship donations of food, medicine, water, clothing, bedding etc. to the affected areas.
Hao Min, Chengdu, China
Rescue teams from Japan,HongKong and TaiWan are gathering in Beijing and ready to start out soon.They are not allowed to into Sichuan in early days just because of safefy problems.The Chinese goverment is doing the best to save lives.Premier Wen is really great and worth the highest respect!
wangyun, Beijing, China
So the American Government is going to give $500,000. How mean is that?
Les H, Zhangzhou, China
Ok I understand that Chinese government has the human resources for rescue project and a few foreign aid workers are not going to make a huge difference plus it being dangerous. But they need vast amount of food and shelter which Red Cross can bring in. I want to my donation to get to work.
Kun Huo, Cambridge, Canada
I'm Chinese myself and I'm glad to see people are aware that certain bias exits. However, the government really should accept foreign rescue, especially specialists from Taiwan and Japan. It has been 72 hours and we need all we can get to save the people out there.
mis bai, Beijing , China
I think many people all of the world are caring for the people in diaster area, we never give up any life in disaster, we are all with them. Yes, I'm chinese, I'm also proud of my country.
Hana, Zhengzhou, China
This foreign senior aid worker's comment shows that he is very arrogant, has no basic knowledge about size of the disaster in Sichuan. It is very likely he will be end up to be rescued by chinese people there. He cannot speak one words in Sichuan dialect.
Don, london, uk
Exemplary. Yes. I'd expect nothing less.
The country is almost "used" to natural disasters. Back in the 1990s, there was a major flood almost every summer.
As for the soldiers, I should think their performance have been "a bit" better than the American soldiers when Katrina struck.
ed, london,
The vicious title of this article only tries to grab readers' eyeballs, while it also reveals the always biased views against China.
Nick, Qingdao, China
What difference is 10-20 aid workers going to make when 60,000 Chinese soldiers and relief teams have been mobilised? Thats not to mention the doctors and nurses.
There is a time and place, and this isn't the time for foreign aid workers to be complaining about not being let in.
Pete, Cov,
The Chinese government responded very quickly to this unexpected disaster. Our Prime Minister is in Sichuan now. Ordinary Chinese people are able to know the lastest news from TV news. People are donating money and blood verywhere in big cities and universities. People are very united.
Bolin Li, Beijing, China
Maybe there are misunderstanding, the Chinese governor don't allow the foreign aid terms to come to Sichuan because the area is not safe.18 quakes had been monitored since the devastating earthquake.It could happen at any time. The situation is not good. We don't wanna foreign friends are in danger.
Steven, Qingdao, China
I want to say the rescue efforts mounted so quickly & efficiently by the Chinese, has been impressive.
I can see imported help would in fact delay some of their work, they would have to be instructed ferried to the earthquake zones & as has been pointed out would not speak the language.
maggie millington, brittany, france
500,000 dollars for a 7.9 earthquake? Stingy Americans.....
Robert Elder, Melbourne , Australia
Please don't be hypocritical. The government really means it when they say that the conditions are dangerous. Just look at the photos of the place. They are doing it out of concern, not of fear.
The Chinese government has truly been exemplary this time.
Henry Yin, Cambridge, MA, USA
If the Chinese Communists do not want aid workers then so be it. In the end they wil have no one to blame but themselves. There are plenty of other places on Earth where the aid workes will be welcomed with open arms.
Cuban Pete, Washington, DC, USA
Because China has a billion people they can throw at this therefore foreign teams aren't needed is ridiculous.There were people being found a week after hurricane Katrina. To delay accepting foreign teams because of safety only kills more Chinese and speaks to the hubiris of their government.
Allen, Seattle, USA
It's true that we have great difficulties in transportations of rescuing people and machines and only part of liberartion army have find way into the stricken area. so I think it is reasonable to decline the interantional rescue temporarily considering the feasibility of rescue and safety of aid
Vivian, Beijing, China
2008 is a difficult year for China. We Chinese should unite and work together to fight against the disaster.
Tina, Jinhua, China
It is really difficult to reach the disaster-hit areas. Even for Chinese aid workers. My colleagues are there right now. The are stopped by the travel condition. We all are in big sadness for this misery. I am sure we would like to have foreign aid workers to help us, we need it indeed.
Lili, Kunming, China
One thing China has in abundance is manpower. The personnel supplied by aid agencies would be a drop in the ocean compared with what is already available within the massive country with its army and other rescue people. And they all speak Chinese.
There is no comparison with Burma/Myanmar.
Filey, Scarborough, UK
The government also considers safety of foreign aid workers.
Tony, BEIJING, China
The best rescue time is 48 hours after earthquake happened. Considering the time that has already passed, there is no way for any international rescue team to get there in time. Plus all roads were cut off and the weather condition doesn't allow helicopters in.
Antony, Arizona, USA
I think our goverment consider there is communicate diffcult between foreign acid workers and people in WENCHUN county.
And it is truth that the transportation in affected areas is obstructed.
People trust Liberation Army troops when they met the natural disaster.
pray for the people in SICHUAN!
lisa, yongkang,
it is obviously that this report cannot give a complete fact to its readers, there is so much personal opinion in it.
echo, Beijing, China
I'm Chinese,i'm proud of my country!
shu chuan, shanghai, China
I must object to the statement that Mr Wang's comments echo those of Myanmar.Myanmar denied access because the Generals don't wish to weaken their grip on power.China has the experience and resources to handle the situation itself. Government response has been swift,unlike FEMA's in the U.S in 2005
Usher (UK Expat), Kunming, PR China
I think it's understandable for the government to refuse foreign workers. First is the transport problem and second is communications. I'm from Chengdu and I know how difficult it is for the Chinese rescue team. Plus no one in the areas can speak English.
Clare, London,