Christine Seib, Steve Hawkes and Siobhan Kennedy
The man, the films, those blondes. Free DVD collection starting this Sunday
The co-founder of one of Britain’s best-known dot-com companies yesterday launched a withering attack on plans for a £30,000-a-year tax on nondomiciled residents.
Consultation on the proposals, which the Treasury hopes will net an additional £500 million a year, closed yesterday. City organisations have inundated the Government with critical responses.
Jason Gissing, co-founder of Ocado, told The Times that the home-shopping group would not have got off the ground in the current climate, given the Chancellor’s proposed crack-down on overseas tycoons.
Mr Gissing hit out at Alistair Darling’s “poor judgment” and said that there was a growing feeling that he “could not be trusted”.
The Treasury proposed that nondoms pay £30,000 a year in tax after they have lived in the UK for more than seven years.
The Government acted after the Conservatives paved the way by raising the issue, a move that, The Times has learnt, has infuriated some Tory donors.
Nondoms also face new capital gains and asset taxes. Previously, private equity bosses and City figures had been accused of avoiding tax on their wealth by using nondom status.
Ocado, which started in 2002, delivers Waitrose goods to 15.5 million people. It is understood to have raised half of its £300 million start-up funding from nondoms.
Mr Gissing said: “We are irritated because the Chancellor has increased capital gains tax in a knee-jerk reaction to criticism of the private equity industry. [The tax] actually penalises people like us who have started a business, created 3,000 jobs and created a new service. Then he says he’s going to penalise the nondoms who finance businesses like ours and get them off the ground.”
Simon Walker, chief executive of the British Venture Capital Association, yesterday gave warning that the proposed changes are already harming the UK’s reputation. “My worry is that the welcome mat is getting rather worn out,” he said. “When I was in New York last month the impression I got from American firms is that London is not as welcoming as it used to be.”
The private equity industry stands to be hit hard by the new regime, since many of the big firms in London, such as Blackstone and KKR, are based in the US and employ many American executives in the UK. One source said that it was not the partners in the big firms who would leave Britain but the many more junior executives who earn £200,000 to £300,000. They would see the proposed £30,000 tax as a significant increase in their outgoings.
The CBI, the London Investment Banking Association and many other City bodies said that they had responded to the Treasury consultation.
The CBI said that nondoms contributed more than £7 billion a year to the Exchequer and that there was a “great deal of room for error” in the Treasury prediction of a £500 million annual gain from the new taxes.
The CBI estimated that up to 8,000 of the 120,000 registered nondoms could leave the UK to avoid the payment if it is introduced, rather than the 3,000 estimated by the Government.
Some of the Conservative Party’s highest-placed City donors are thought to be livid that it was the Tories who raised the possibility of a flat-rate tax for nondoms. The Tories proposed a £25,000 annual charge, but, unlike the Government’s plan, they did not intend to include scrutiny of offshore assets owned by nondoms.
One donor said: “When the Conservatives came up with the idea of a charge I know a lot of people were very, very annoyed because they felt that the party was opening up Pandora’s Box and giving Labour the opportunity to move on the issue.”
According to a survey published yesterday by the City of London Corporation, the UK tax system has lost its competitive edge at a time when rival nations have reduced their tax rates. It said the UK had an “unpredictable and uncertain” approach to tax, with many of the 35 City firms questioned citing nondom changes as negative.
In a separate survey of finance professionals around the world, the corporation found that although London is still the leading global financial centre, New York is close to overtaking it.
Ins and outs of the tax rules for non-doms
Existing tax rules:
Non-doms do not pay income tax on overseas income or gains.
Non-doms pay income tax, capital gains tax and inheritance tax on all their UK income and assets.
Income tax is charged depending on what they earn in the UK.
Non-doms must also pay inheritance tax at 40 per cent on their UK estate if it is worth more than £300,000, even if they no longer live in the UK.
Government’s proposals:
All non-doms to lose personal allowance for income and capital gains tax immediately, unless agree to be taxed on worldwide assets.
£30,000 annual charge for non-doms once they have lived in the country for seven years.
Tax on capital gains made on UK assets in offshore trusts.
Conservatives’ proposals:
Flat charge of £25,000 for all non-doms. This charge would be creditable against foreign tax.
The debate rages
Richard Lambert, CBI director-general:
“At a time of growing economic uncertainty it is vital we do all we can to keep wealth generators in the country, not make them feel unwelcome. Non-doms have been an important part of the UK’s success andadministrations have provided a warm welcome. Partly as a result of their presence London is the world’s leading financial and business centre”
Roger Jeary, director, Unite trade union:
“Unite supports Government plans to tax the non-dom residents who have been able to evade their tax obligations for too long. We believe these people should pay their fair share. This includes the estimated 75 per cent of senior staff at private equity firms who, by their own admission, pay less tax than their cleaners”
Matthew Elliott, TaxPayers’ Alliance chief:
“Some people wrongly think that hitting non-doms could benefit ordinary taxpayers, but this is not the case. Hurting Britain’s ability to attract the internationally mobile would be a disaster for the economy”
Simon Walker, chief executive, British Venture Capital Association:
“I don’t want businesses leaving London and setting up shop elsewhere in Europe because of uncertainty about tax rates, about the treatment of foreigners or just because the welcome mat was getting a little worn”
Ian Harrison, director, London Investment Banking Association:
“We put in a substantial response, expressing our concern over the way the consultation was handled, with insufficient time to explore the key issues, and also over some of the specific proposals”
Frank Haskew, head of tax, Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales:
“Our view is that there is fundamental problems with the legislation. Potentially, anyone coming to the UK who has investment income of more than £1,000 from overseas will almost inevitably have to fill in a UK tax return”
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Our Credit Clinic has free help and advice
2007
£47,700
2007
£41,899
2008
£41,445
Great car insurance deals online
£33,000
Macmillan Cancer Support
Central/South West
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£30k OTE
Meltwater News
Nationwide
100K
Confidential
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Homes Available on a shared Ownership Basis
Great Investment, River Views
By Funway – Thailand
from £589pp
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Not all non doms are super rich. Some come from 3rd world countries. Some, like me, use foreign income to support charitable projects in their home countries where state systems do not exist and individuals are expected to play their part.
I am particularly appalled that £30k ANNUALLY that has nothing to do with the UK - it wasn't earned here and it won't be spent here- will be diverted from a sustainable farming project to help disabled school children. This money makes a real difference in my home country - it will be disappear into the vast machine [of incompetence?] here and never be noticed.
I have chosen to live here and happily pay taxes on my UK affairs. I employ UK nationals, do not rely on state systems and make a significant net contribution to this country. I have traditionally liked the sense of fairness here. This tax isn't fair for people who depend on offshore funds for charitable works. After many years, I will now contemplate leaving, too....
Laurie, Oxford, England
Michael
Think about indirect tax and which group pays a lot of it,
and also the price of any property you own, however having read your comment you're probably not a property owner.
Philip, London,
No account has been taken of the situation of non-doms of modest means. As a South African living in England for many years, and paying tax on income and interest earned in Britiain but not on a small amount of interest earned abroad and not remitted to the UK, which funds foreign trips to SAfrica, I could not possibly pay £30,000 fee which far exceeds the the annual interest earned. With capital on fixed deposit abroad what can I do as this tax seems draconian to those non-doms of modest means?
GERALD SACKS, West Byfleet,
The ignorance and arrogance of some of the comments here just goes to prove 'you get the government you deserve'. I would advise all non-doms - both employees and employers - get out now, whilst your overseas assets are still in tact and protected.
Labour's mask is slipping. They are still the same old bunch of envious socialists that gerrymander their support amongst the work shy.
Edwin, Bucharest,
The unnecessary rush after 5 years of fruitless consultation under GB has led to a lot of irritation and still very incomplete legislation in this regard and on many details which must be lclarified now within 12 days(e.g.offshore mortgages treatment,capital losses acceptance etc.)! Also, the poll tax like nature of it, instead of e.g. a scaled system, upsets many of the small to medium wealthy and usually UK income tax paying nondoms while oligarchs&co., who usually do not pay any UK income tax are basically not impacted by it. Clarifications/ tightenings on remittances are welcome, in the spirit of the original law and should not be complained about. Ideally, the UK should introduce low and fair taxation of capital income, capital gains and inheritances for all residents alike.
George, London,
Ian You live in Japan and clearly are unaware of the UK climate with this governments ill thought out policies time and again.
Also to set up a successful supermarket challenger takes alot of money now. unlike when Tesco, Sainsbury etc started as local shops.
andy, petersfield,
Ian, Tokyo
Ocado is not owned or run by Waitrose. It is a completely independent entity.
Natalie, Northants, UK
Ian in Tokyo, Ocado was not set up by Waitrose. It's a separate operation. They had to raise their own start-up funds.
Alex, London,
But what was so difficult about raising the capital they, Ocado, needed from a UK National Savings Institution? Surely, if you are creating jobs here in the UK, all you need is access to the capital of the nation's, (savings?), on reasonable, free enterprise terms? So the real question to ask the "city" is why was any of the capital Ocado needed sourced from overseas? If you really want to open a Pandora's box, ask that question.
Chris Coles, Medstead, Alton, United Kingdom
Envy and mistrust are very powerful emotions which cloud people's judgement. I am a non-dom and I do not earn the millions stated. I have a house (registered in my parents and my name) overseas which is earning an income, including managing my dad's portfolio of investments in my name.
Those are already taxed by the local governments and now UK wants to tax those income as well. If anyone is interested, I will be winding up my small little business here and moving to Asia by the end of the year. Unfortunately, that means that UK will permanently lose 15 job positions (12 are British citizens) that i currently hire. I know my business is puny but if only 1 in 10 of so many non-doms make the same decision as I do, UK might finally be happy in driving all away jobs from its shores.
Craig, London,
If I could have dodged taxes in that way, I would have been able to put money into Ocado. I wish they would come down harder on tax avoidance.
Michael, London,
Absolute rubbish about Ocado not getting off the ground. The other supermarkets managed to set up delivery operations without tax dodging foreigners being involved.
Ian, Tokyo, Japan