Emma Justice
We've made some changes
to The Sunday Times
Stephanie Painter’s death was swift and painless. At 9.10pm on February 11 she bid her 121 Facebook friends goodbye with one last “poke” (mood: sorrowful), then left the virtual world peacefully with a quick click of the mouse.
“It was hard to kill the profile I’d spent so long creating, but I felt it was the only way out,” says Stephanie, 27, a PA from Fulham, West London. “Facebook was damaging my relationship with my boyfriend to such an extent that if I hadn’t done it we wouldn’t be together now.” For Painter found that what had seemed like an innocent way of reconnecting with old friends and colleagues had opened a huge can of worms.
“Within a couple of months a number of ex-partners and people that I’d had random flings with were asking to be my “friend” in Facebook. I didn’t feel I could decline them and I admit I was intrigued by what they were up to,” she says. “But not only did that ignite unwanted feelings in me, it also made my boyfriend Danny, a 28-year-old TV producer, incredibly insecure. As one of my friends, he could view my profile page, my friends’ list and my ‘wall’ (an area on which messages are posted).
“Reading my ex’s flirty messages, however innocent, made him insanely jealous. He hated the fact that I was in touch with men I’d once slept with and that some of them had posted up old pictures of us together which I had no power to remove. In the end, Facebook was causing so many arguments between us that I decided the best thing would be to log off. As soon as my Facebook profile died, our relationship improved.”
Painter is not the only one of the social networking site’s 31 million users to have committed what is being dubbed “Facebook suicide”. Although it’s impossible to estimate exactly how many people have “deactivated” (the site has yet to release figures), there are a growing number of Facebook suicide groups on the site. (One, the Facebook Mass Suicide Club, encourages members to “cancel your account before it consumes you. Join this group so we can do it together!” So far, 143 people have joined.)
Started in 2004 by Mark Zuckerberg, a student at Harvard, Facebook is now the 13th most used search engine in the world, with two million members in the UK and 150,000 new people signing up every day. Eclipsing Friends Reunited in popularity and media buzz, barely a day goes by without a story in the press about the site (see panel facing page), from privacy concerns over its plans to make profiles accessible through search engines such as Google, to reports that more than 70 per cent of British businesses have moved to restrict or ban Facebook, including British Gas and Lloyds TSB.
Considered more popular with slightly older and more middle-class users than other networking sites, such as MySpace and Bebo, it has recently made the transition from niche concept to something with mass appeal. So why are people deciding to put a virtual noose around their online necks?
It’s easy to be misinterpreted
Carolyn Axtell, a senior researcher at the Institute of Work Psychology and Management School at Sheffield University, thinks, as in Painter’s case, that it has a lot to do with the potential for misunderstanding. She says: “There are a limited set of cues available on sites like this. You don’t get the subtleties of voice tone, facial expressions or body language you usually have when interacting with others and that can make interpreting the meaning of messages difficult. You can write something flippantly, which others take seriously, or come across as aggressive when that’s not your intention at all. I can see how relationships can be damaged as a result and when that happens people will want to leave to put things right.”
Matt Holme, 24, a derivatives broker from Pimlico, West London, says he wrote his Facebook suicide note after he saw pictures of himself online which he didn’t even realise had been taken. “When I was introduced to friends of friends, they’d recognise me from my profile on Facebook. I no longer had any anonymity and that was disconcerting.”
Phillip Hodson, a fellow of the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP), says: “Building a Facebook profile is one way that individuals can identify themselves, making them feel important and accepted. But this can lead to disappointment once people realise how insignificant their online existence really is. Not only are online friends not necessarily real friends, they can turn out to be people you don’t wish to know at all. I’m not surprised that those who feel their virtual life is unsatisfying commit online suicide. I really think we make a mistake if we hope to find our collective raison d’être via sites such as Facebook.”
“I’d rather spend time with people in person”
Clare Missingham, 34, a yoga teacher from Crouch End, North London, logged off a month ago when she realised how pointless her online profile had become. “I’d already kept in touch with the friends I wanted to, so apart from communicating with a few people overseas (whose e-mail addresses I had anyway), it wasn’t much use to me. It didn’t make me feel more connected and I’d rather spend quality time with people in person than sit in front of a computer turning them into vampires or buying them virtual presents [both are online applications you can add to your profile].”
But are there more serious psychological issues that could be triggered by reconnecting with old friends or flames? Should the ghosts of the past remain just that? Over a lifetime it’s normal to lose touch with people as interests and circumstances change, but Facebook alters the natural ebb and flow of friendship. “Renewing old ties in this way can feel false,” says Andrew G. Marshall, a marital therapist and the author of I Love You But I’m Not In Love With You (Bloomsbury, £8.99).
“Generally people have just a handful of really close friends. If you feel the need to get in touch with someone from the past, you have to ask yourself why you do. It could be indicative of a problem or unhappiness in your current self and, therefore, a desire to reconnect with a younger one. But once people realise this is not a solution, they’ll leave and try to solve them another way,” Marshall says.
Hodson agrees. “The idea of renewing old friendships is appealing but it doesn’t come without difficulties and dangers. You may still be lusting after the girl in 3B, but is she lusting after you? If you were bullied at school and suddenly the bully asks to be your “friend”, all those bad feelings and insecurities you felt as a ten-year-old could come flooding back,” he says.
Patricia Rogers, a counsellor and fellow of the BACP, even worries that the feelings that lead to Facebook suicide could trigger the loneliness and lack of self-esteem felt by people who really do take their own lives.
“It could be incredibly damaging for the ego to realise that you haven’t got as many friends as you thought you had, or that those friends aren’t particularly meaningful,” she says.
“Comparing yourself with others, a big preoccupation on sites such as Facebook, can be damaging psychologically so, as a precaution, I think that people who leave should be carefully monitored, or at least checked up on, and then referred to counselling resources if necessary.”
Getting a real life
Yet other users say they’ve ended their lives in the virtual world for far more prosaic reasons – so that they can resume life in the real one.
According to Facebook, users spend an average of 20 minutes a day on the site although a survey by uSwitch. com found that others spend more than ten hours a week on virtual networking sites, the equivalent of 24 days a year (think how many pub lunches with real friends could be enjoyed in that time).
Increasing numbers of employers are banning staff from using social networking sites. Metropolitan Police officers have been warned that they face the sack, and universities have started using it to catch out students behaving badly. So perhaps it’s no surprise that some people would rather commit Facebook suicide than that of the professional sort.
Fiona Blamey, 36, director of the PR agency Prompt Communications, killed her profile after a month because she felt that it mixed up her personal and professional lives. “Being on the internet under my real name makes me feel anxious. It’s so easy to be indiscreet on there, but it feels a bit like getting drunk at university and playing the Truth Game. It’s fun at the time, but afterwards you really regret it. You long to be more guarded, retain yourself-respect and maybe even a bit of mystique,” she says.
When things get personal, you’re vulnerable
“Self-disclosure can indeed be a problem on the internet,” says Axtell. “The fact that you can’t see or hear other people makes it easier to reveal yourself in a way you might not be comfortable with. You become less conscious of the individuals involved (including yourself), less inhibited, less embarrassed and less concerned about how you will be evaluated.
“Once you realise that things have become too personal, you’ll feel vulnerable; who wants everyone to know what you did on the weekend? Logging off becomes the only way to recover privacy.”
Martin Cloake, 42, a sports copywriter from Lewisham, South London, says he left his Facebook life a few months ago because he also felt uncomfortable about putting his private life on public display.
“It all felt a bit stalkerish, the way that you could find out what people were doing almost daily, see pictures of them (or yourself) that other people had posted and trawl through other people’s lists of friends to see who you knew.”
For Holme, the last straw came when he logged on at the start of January and noticed that one of his friends had changed their profile on Christmas Day. “That was it; I shot myself on the spot.”
Now it seems an increasing number of people are doing the same. So before I start sharpening my own knife, I’d just like to say that if my 91 friends fancy meeting me for a drink in the afterlife, please give me a call.
Facebook – a beginner’s guide
Facebook allows you to create and online personal profile that other people can view. All you need is a valid e-mail address. You can enter as many (or few) details as you like, including your birth date, your relationship status, your political views, where you went to school and even your favourite books. You then start searching for people you know. If they’re already on the site you can ask them to be your “friend”, or you can invite them to join Facebook. While someone can look you up and see who your friends are, they can’t access your profile unless you have approved them as a friend. You can change your privacy settings to limit the information that people on the site can see.
Friends can send messages to each other, write on each other’s “walls” (personal message boards), buy virtual gifts and drinks, and upload photographs or videos. Every time you log on you can view your “news feed”, which alerts you to what your friends have been doing on the site – groups joined, messages posted, new friends made, etc.
Logging on – a healthy checklist
Spend more time on real relationships
According to research released last week, social networking sites do not help you to make real friends. Even for those with hundreds of online friends, the number of friends they class as “close” still remains at the real world average of five and are usually people they have met face-to-face.
Be careful who your friends are
Research reveals that 41 per cent of Facebook users are willing to disclose personal information to strangers and a recent study by the Danish security firm CSIS revealed that social networking sites can be used to create a veneer of trust that leaves internet users and businesses at risk. Data harvesting and conmen can use information posted on sites, so review your privacy settings regularly.
At work
Under human-rights legislation, employees do not have the right to confidential use of internet and e-mail facilities at work. In addition, the employer has a duty to monitor the use of company facilities to avoid bullying or harassment. You may also be in breach of your contract if you are found to be using the internet for private purposes.
Beware of the bullies
Research by the children’s charity NCH and Tesco Mobile found that one in six children in the South West had been the victim of cyber-bullying and recent research from America revealed that one teenager in four admit to cyber-bullying and many use social networking sites to target victims. Parents should familiarise themselves with sites their child uses and talk regularly to their child about online activity.
Don’t be a slouch potato
A recent British Chiropractic Association survey revealed that 50 per cent of 16 to 24-year-olds were suffering from back pain, compared with 18 per cent three years ago. Back-care specialists believe this can be linked to increased use of laptop computers. Using laptops for extended periods is a big nono. Make sure that you use yours at a table and, if you can, use a docking station that allows you to use an external monitor and keyboard.
Keep an eye off it
Eye strain, permanent eye-damage and glaucoma have all been linked to regular computer use. So take a break and exercise your eyes by closing them tightly for a second, then opening them widely. Refocus your eyes every 15 minutes, which helps to avoid eye train. Glance across the room or out of the window, at an object at least 20 feet away, and back again.
Get set up
To avoid back and neck pain and repetitive strain injury, make sure that your desktop computer is set up for optimum comfort and safety. You can download a diagram of how to set up your work station at: rsi.org.uk/pdf/correct_work_station.pdf
How the new breed of location based mobile services can find your nearest cashpoint, restaurant or wi-fi hotspot
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Are you California dreaming? Explore the wonders of the Golden State. Also enter our fantastic competition
See the best entries in this year's competition
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget

Win one of 2,000 Garnier Ambre Solaire Moisturising Protection Milks

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


50% off top restaurants, book online

2006
£189,500
NW England
2008/08
£169,950
NW England
2007/57
£35,000
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £82,000 per annum
Birmingham Women's Hospital
Birmingham
To £28k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool/Teeside
£
Up to £66,000 per annum
Hertfordshire County Council
South East
To £38k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool
2 Bathrooms, Balcony and Garden
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Dining, Shopping & Riverside Pk
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
The solution is simple: she should have declined the friend requests from people she didn't want to be in touch with. I do it frequently. After all, if you don't want to be in touch with these people anyway, why worry about offending them by declining their request? I don't think anyone ever really gets upset about declined requests anyway.
Willo the Wisp, London,
Andrew in Seattle - please don't assume they are telling the truth. Most of them are probably feeling the same as you, why else would they be on Facebook? You gotta get out there in the fresh air, other people's lives are not as perfect as most of them make out! I'm moving along in years but I found out a long time ago that a smile (practice in the mirror) opens lots of doors and gets a positive reaction from others. You are a unique and wonderful person, keep telling yourself that because it is true, you don't have to measure yourself by the real or imagine success of others.
redandover60, Hayes, Middlesex, England
I got rid of my Facebook account by sending an e-mail to them. Everybody else seems so happy and it only reminds me how lonely I am. I see other people accomplish great things in school or work and I can't help but compare myself to them. It also makes talking to somebody in real life less exciting if you've seen their profile and know everything about them. Sometimes the less you know, the better.
Andrew, Seattle, USA
I agree with the fact that it does have a slight stalker-approach. The fact that you go into the profile of a friend and see messages from someone else that you don't even know (but they do) and you find out what they've been doing. I just think it's foolish to post items for other friends-of-friends to see - Use the email tool, there is one. As for all this poking and slapping - It's a pathetic and childish way of communication and provides one second of fun for what? Nothing. The only applications worth sharing on the site are the 'Quiz-style' ones. They are truly useful for interaction or just passing-the-time and learning some useless information. But I'd still rather do a quiz down the pub! I use facebook because i was lured into it by friends i still speak to by other means and we meet up from time to time. It's addictive at first but now I'm not too keen on it, same with myspace (although i still prefer it to facebook as it's a chance to be creative and learn some webdesign).
Annemarie, Oxon, UK
This is the more juvenile standpoint I've ever come across. If your relationships can't even survive a little online community, how do you expect them to survive through real life?
c, Windsor, Canada
i have just deactivated my account after 6 months as a fb member! i feel a real sense of relief now that i'm back in the real world, but slightly worried about the space it will leave. facebook was becoming a bigger part of my life than it should have which admittedly was my doing. i have been in a vulnerable situation this year & found facebook a way of occupying my mind & avoid feeling lonely however, like anything that you get a buzz from whether it be receiving a poke from a goodlooking friend or drinking a glass of wine ultimately fb has been an escape, a way of avoiding issues i should really be concerntrating on, yes i felt less lonely but it was superficial, the people i was connectng with were people from a past that i had chosen to leave behind and for a reason. real friends are friends because they are around you not people who's pics you look on screen. i will admit i was getting a bit of a facebook addict but after a wake up call i'm on the road to recovery!
heidi
heidi cooke, south london, uk
For my part and the majority of my "real" friends who use facebook, it is just another way of staying in touch - I prefer messaging on facebook to email because I can see a picture of the person I'm contacting. It's great for finding friends you have lost touch with and keeping in touch with those who live abroad. I think that it needs to be used responsibly and it propbably is open to abuse at some level, but so much of our communication these days is!
Emma John, Brighton, UK
Facebook seemed extremely dangerous and disconcerting to me from the moment I logged on... I think from this day hence, facebook will, in its way, kill almost every relationship going..
It pretty much destroyed mine.. I dont think anyone can be surprised when their partner runs off with someone from facebook, in fact It will probably become more surprising if they don't... I mean people already do enough of that don't they? And that's before we were able to invite ourselves back into the lives of people we never should have been able to... People make many silly mistakes when the opportunity presents itself, never mind when it's rammed down their throats...
And that's without even considering all the privacy issues..
In a couple of years I imagine the typical 'pulling' scene in pubs on a saturday night will involve slipping out back to pull up someone's profile on FB before running back in to 'coincidentally' love all the same films, books, etc as the target... And worse....
Ben, Olney, Bucks,
Every thing in life should be done in moderate, even if you are facebook addict, you should learn how to control your time, other wise it will be harmful, having a virtual life on the net is not so bad, considering that you know how to manage your time using it, above article is excellent, specially for new beginners and even old users of facebook, just take the good and leave the rest.
Ihab, Dubai, UAE
The comment about the boyfriend being insecure I agree with another person's post that the boyfriend was already jealous. He obviously had some insecurities that he needed to work out and that his girlfriend talking to old flingd indeed just amplified it. All in all it was a good idea for his girlfriend to commit "Facebook Suicide" to save what was important to her; her boyfriend. It comes down to men and women doing what's right for themselves or significant others to save a situation. For example if drinking is a problem for someone else that is dear to you and you care about, then y ou should stop drinking or have it monitored by that person.
Bill, Fort Smith,
facebook is a boon for the more technologically-challenged amongst us. I run a couple of common-interests groups, and I am absolutely incapable of creating an acceptable website. Facebook allows me to do without the hassle. On the other hand, I do only use it for this, or for occasional emails between friends, and my 'profile' has no personal information, and is hidden from any kind of search. I agree with other posters who argue that networking sites are only what we make of them; the key is to use them as tools rather than turning them into 'alternate life' shrines.
Dee, London,
You should take a look at ReallyWorried.com
It is the best British website I have seen, and looks as if it will become more popular than Facebook.
Unlike Facebook it is a site that is doing peopl good.
richard, manchetsre, UK
I think it all depends on how you use sites like this. I don't have hundreds of friends on facebook, just as I don't have hundreds of friends in real life. The beauty of a site like this for me is one of contact. I live in Singapore but most of my nearest and dearest are in the UK. A seven-hour time difference makes regular phone calls tricky (not to mention costly) and email is more impersonal than seeing their faces, what they are up to and being able to have a virtual chat. I already feel more in touch with friends back home, even though I've only been on facebook a couple of months.
Elaine, Singapore,
One again something else gets the blame.
The boyfriend was insecure in the relationship. That's the problem, not Facebook.
Sort that out - no problem.
Paul C, Wigan, England
Thought provoking and really well wriiten I liked Marshall's viewpoint in the middle. Social networking Sites and sites like twittr makes me wonder making a online archived copy of our is good or not?
But one point to be taken is: you be aware how to navigate through these sites. Being digitally ignorant and naive is not good. else you might as cranberries sung: wake and smell the coffee on the computer!
Vinukumar, Bangalore, India
Like so many other internet related developments, Facebook and the other social networking sites are neither good nor bad in themselves but depend for their utility on how they are used or abused. I have found it worthwhile to both establish and maintain contact with people who because of distance or other factors I wouldn't otherwise get to know. But if it's used as a form of student prank-sheet listing drinking and other actvities, which are not wrong in themselves but not really worthy of global broadcast, then of course it is wasteful and potentially harmful. Make of it what you will.
John Stobart, Oakham, Rutland
Personally I think FB is fantastic..it allows me to see my friends pics from my home back in Aust and if you have any intelligence you can limit the amont of exposure you have. Privacy settings are there for a reason. Also if you aren't on it you have no way of know what pics etc people are posting of you and thus can not regulate these by removing tags etc. It is very sad if yu feel like FB is all encompassing as it should never be this but I remeber people dissing mobile phones when they were first launched..
C. Wilson, london, uk
This is overblown. I deleted my Facebook profile when I left school, since I'd mainly used it to keep track of college acquaintances. Since I was never going to see them again, I didn't need it anymore and didn't want to leave all that personal information online indefinitely. The big reaction is being caused by the word suicide. If we called it, "taking your ball and going home," no one would care.
Sara, Los Angeles, California
It's really an eye opener in the sense that here in India we are just beginning to delve deep into social networking sites such as Orkut among others. What has been happening in Britain must find a way here sooner rather than later. So..Thankfully our society is not so 'Open' as to get frightened by ex-revealations as in the case in the article, but nevertheless we are seeing more and more crimes which in some way or the other has an Orkut connection. So, its coming fast than normal. Thankfully, I am a guy not a gal and so less vulnerable to cyber crimes. They even altered a woman chief minister's profile on Orkut. So many sites are coming up claiming as 'safest networking sites' refllecting in the names itself the hidden danger lurking around. It's surely a big debate nowadays here in India. Internet usage is percolating to the small towns and may be one can say that if such 'virtual suicides' will start happening than the Internet would have come of age in India too as in UK now.
Pritam Sinha, New Delhi, India
I completely agree. So often on the internet you face the dire choice of either seeming insipid by having to dilute the force your words with emoticons (such as :p and ;) and :D ) or simply seeming more aggressive or rude than you really are. While it does offer great opportunities for catching up with friends, one test of a true friendship is how much effort you're prepared to make to keep that friendship together and keep in touch. At any rate, the benefit of such opportunities is often outweighed by the negative aspects: some of the most unpleasant people I've ever met are - well - people I've actually never met. Which is quite a shame, because in one or two such cases I would have much enjoyed being able to see them face-to-face, clearly speak my mind, turn on my heel and walk briskly away. With social networking sites this simply isn't an option. Nevermind the shameless and unnecessary comparisons of people.
It was fun while it lasted, but have such sites had their time?
John Warton, Stockport, England
i could never commit facebook suicide. as a student it's a vital part of the campus bubble and i'd miss out on so many events and all the gossip.
also, if it wern't for facebook i wouldn't be with my boyfriend now. we met at a uni party but never exchanged names or numbers, i randomly saw him write on a mutual friends wall a few weeks later and decided to add him, lots of virtual banter ensued and once we saw eachother out in public again the rest was history.
i've made friends on faceook that have lead to real relationships as i then see them on campus and ive been in contact with childhood friends.
facebook is not the problem, it's people's will power, if you limit yourself to only checking it breifly once a day then it's no more intrusive than checking your phone or emails.
bluebell, london,
Thank god there are other people who feel like me! Facebook is an extension of High School where things like amount of "friends", money, education, travel experience, life experiences, cause people to try to one up people. Get a life people! a real one that involves the present not the past.
Laura, peterborough, Ontario