Get 20% off your bill at Pizza Express
Sir, There can have been few more depressing headlines recently than “MPs demand £23,000 grant to hide expenses” (May 27). The report goes on to suggest that the House of Commons Commission is about to recommend a massive increase in MPs’ salaries in addition to ruling on expenses. The commission is made up of MPs themselves, all of whom (but none of us) will have the chance to vote on its recommendations.
The news will rankle with the police, members of the Armed Forces, pensioners and many others. It is time to set up an independent commission, devoid of any MPs in its composition, to look at the rates of pay and expenses for MPs, and to make recommendations on which MPs will vote. Such a commission would be guided by the needs of the economy, fairness and the availability of suitable alternative candidates for the job of MP.
Anthony Hollis
Camberley, Surrey
Sir, MPs impose severe restrictions on local councillors regarding expenses. Receipts are required, minimal expenditure is expected and recorded declarations must be made of any received hospitality above the value of £25. Yet they don’t seem to wish similar expectations to be applied to themselves.
They are also of the opinion that they are unfairly remunerated for their efforts. Councillors receive a fraction of MPs’ salaries but have vastly more impact on the day-to-day lives of their constituents. In fact, MPs often pass issues on to councillors for them to handle.
Cllr David Hibbert
Oldham
Sir, Any company that requires its employees to work away from home provides them with appropriate accommodation when they do so. I see no reason why we should not reimburse MPs in the same situation, whether by providing flats or houses for them or by supporting mortgage payments on second homes required in order to do their job.
However, once the person is no longer an MP, I see no reason why he or she should be allowed to continue to benefit from owning a second home which, generally, will have risen significantly in value and which the taxpayer has provided. Once no longer required, these second homes should be sold and the proceeds returned to the public purse.
Rowel W. Samuels
Harrow, Middx
Sir, The answer to the second home problem is for the Government to provide accommodation in blocks of flats. These would be furnished to a high standard, have the necessary security features and be fully serviced. No more need for our overworked MPs to traipse round Peter Jones deciding which cooker, fridge or carpets to buy. No more time wasted arranging for someone to come and clean the windows or scrape the moss off the patio. There could even be a shuttle bus service to the House.
Nigel Barraclough
Burford, Oxon
Sir, I remember being pleased that my first teaching salary broke the £1,000 a year barrier, but I noticed that this was less than the pay of a newly elected MP. I hoped to catch up one day. Forty years later, after much experience, many promotions and a fiftyfold increase, I am still behind.
Jack Lonergan
Emeritus Professor of Applied Linguistics, St Albans, Herts
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£100k
The National Skills Academy for Social Care
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
£75k - £85k
Confidential
London
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
$3.5 million
Also avaliable for rent
Times Online Property Search will help you find it
Amazing Far East Offers - Visit Hong Kong
from £499pp
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
One rule for us and one for them. All other citizens are subject to tax rules for expenses and benefits in kind. Why not MPs who are mostly in the business because of the dictum "If you can, do, if you can't, be a politician", also "Exercise power not truth".
Richard, Derby, Derbyshire
Police and armed forces pay is fixed at a level which will encourage recruitment. If the pay does not meet prospective candidates' aspirations, they will not join. I wonder what the necessary level should be for Members of Parliament?
Peter Cressall, La Lucila, Argentina
i have a Labour MP in my family and i can say without a shed of doubt that he got his position because he is a scot who made friendly with blair. he is a great man, orator, and financier but has no qualifications to justify making him an MP.
Richard, london, england
There are some ridiculous comments on here. Why should MP's have their spending reviewed? No other workers in the state sector do. Similarly, the fact that the FOI Act has been used purely by the scandal seeking brigade to name and shame MP's is a further sad indictment of our petulant society.
Jon, Shanghai,
I completely agree with Nigel Barraclough's comment. One hundred percent!!!!
Bill Channon, Francestown, United States
It's quite amusing how the MP's are very reluctant to spend their own money on getting a 2nd home up to their own standards, but don't think twice before spending the publics money to do the same.
Give them one salary, no allowances, and put the rest into the abolishing tuition fees.
Andrew Dawson, Salford,
M.P.s houses should be as tied homes elsewhere. They should not have ownership ,as it is public money being given. At the end of the time in Parliment ,the houses should be returned to the treasury,as an asset.
If they are left in the ownership of the M.P. ,they must be thought of as salary.
Irena White, Shrewsbury, U.K.
Buy a selection of housing in London (and Edinburgh, Cardiff and Belfast for similar problems in regional parliaments), eg family houses or flats. The housing can then be leased or given freely to the MPs and at least then any rise in the value of the housing is to the benefit of the public.
Jennifer Wilson, Glasgow, Scotland
This was the nail in the coffin for us, no longer can I condone this farce of a democracy, so I'll expect to be dumped on whatever the outcome in Westminister and will be marking my ballots 'spoiled'. (my wife will be somewhat more candid!)
I no longer consider us British, and that is a tradegy.
matthew, lancashire, uk
Let's face it: Britain has not been a Democracy since 1906 when we started paying MPs, thus making them salaried minions of the State, Furthermore it should be made a crime to donate money (as opposed to one's time) to any politician or Party.
Keith MANN, Broxbourne,
If a Civil Servant had done even one of the MP's fiddles, he wouls have been sacked, lost his pension and been sent to jail
ken stephenson, lee on solent, England
MPs shouldn't be paid anything... hopefully that would reduce the amount of time wasted in Parliament to one evening a week.
Constituency work can be done at home.
If MPs have a day job, they will understand how it is for the rest of us. Being an MP shouldn't be a career, but a public service
Peter Hollander, Canterbury,
Doubtless everyone is enjoying their self-righteous indignation at the expenses claimed by some MPs. A proper review of MPs pay and expenses will most likely cause the overall costs to rise. The same thing happened when the "abuse" of the NHS by consultants was followed by "strict" contracts.
Nick, Rotherham, UK
Look at the salaries of MPs. Is there any wonder that the sorry bunch that comprise the cabinet are such a talentless crowd, the majority of whom have barely ever held a real job in their lives?
Nick, Rotherham, UK
What a thought, that Chelsea Barracks need not have been sold at all! What ever happened to the old Millbank Military Hospital? That would have been even more handy for them!
S. Barraclough, Huddersfield, W. Yorkshire
the european model marches on--let them eat cake-whilst the ruling political elite keeps adding to their trough
terry sullivan, morden,
Anthony Hollis makes the point that "economy" should be one of the measures used to judge MPs' expenses claims.
In 2006/07 Brentford MP Mrs Anne Keene claimed £18,701 for living away from home.
The are at least 4 trains/hr from Brentford to Waterloo and a Monthly Season Ticket costs just £89.90
Peter Hooper, Windsor, UK
These MPs must have a death wish.Do they not realize how much their constituents despise them for their dishonest exploitation of the rules they set for themselves?
How many of the current members could really earn more than £60000 a year outside the House?
Asmodeus, London,
These MPs must have a death wish.Do they not realize how much their constituents despise them for their dishonest exploitation of the rules they set for themselves?
How many of the current members could really earn more than £60000 a year outside the House?
Asmodeus, London,
Sir.
MP's should be housed in block accomodation of exactly the same standard as provided to serving soldiers. They would then find out what awful conditions our troops and their families face; and also have to pay taxes on to use. I guarantee the derelict flats would soon be fixed.
Richard Mason, Oxford, UK