David Smith and Dominic O’Connell
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today
Alistair Darling will this week offer an olive branch to multinationals in an attempt to head off a threatened corporate exodus from Britain.
He will try to defuse a row over the taxation of foreign profits by insisting Treasury reforms are not intended as a revenue-raising measure.
Darling will also indicate that the government is willing to grant a concession on the key issue in the row – the treatment of intellectual property held offshore, such as brands and patents.
The Sunday Times revealed a fortnight ago that a powerful delegation from the secretive Multinational Chairmen’s Group had visited Downing Street to lobby Gordon Brown and Darling on the issue.
They warned that if the proposals on intellectual property went ahead, big companies might have to pay hundreds of millions of pounds more in tax. The Treasury plan would speed the move of corporate headquarters out of Britain to lower-tax regimes, the delegation said.
Darling will try to mend fences with the business community in his speech to the CBI’s annual dinner on Tuesday.
The chancellor will insist that there was no intention of widening the tax net and using the new proposals as a measure to increase revenue.
He will say that the Treasury’s final proposals, due to be published in July, will take into account the impact of the change on individual sectors, to ensure that none will face higher tax bills as a result.
“The Treasury has been looking hard into this,” a senior official said. “We’ve been at pains to make clear that any changes should be revenue neutral, but clearly we will also be looking at how individual sectors are affected and at the issues around intellectual property. We are absolutely committed to ensuring the UK tax regime remains competitive.”
Darling is also expected to unveil the membership of the new multinational forum on tax he announced at the end of last month “to discuss ways in which the tax system can provide the long-term certainty multinational companies need”, and he will set out the broader strategic areas on which the group will concentrate.
Significantly, its members will include Julian Heslop, chief financial officer of Glaxo Smith Kline (GSK), one of the intellectual property-rich companies that has raised concerns about the taxation of foreign profits.
Another member will be Douglas Flint, chief financial officer of HSBC. Representatives of both companies attended the recent meeting at Downing Street. The panel will be chaired by Treasury financial secretary Jane Kennedy.
Several high-profile companies, including Shire Pharmaceuticals and United Business Media, have already announced they will move out of the UK to Ireland to pay less tax. Several others, including WPP, GSK and Astra Zeneca, have said they are considering their options.
The current row grew out of proposals published last year to reform the way earnings from foreign subsidiaries are taxed.
A discussion document proposed making foreign dividends tax-exempt – a move welcomed by finance directors. The fine print of the document, however, contained exceptions, including a proposal to tax intellectual property held offshore.
Multinationals say this could bring earnings from overseas brands, patents and designs within the reach of the UK taxman.
Legal experts say one way forward for the Treasury would be to introduce a “motive” test, a feature of the current system governing foreign earnings. Companies would only pay up if it could be shown they deliberately moved activities offshore to avoid tax.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
people don't realize that tax in the UK (aside from VAT) is actually lower than it is in the states. my mother pays close to 5000 pounds a year in "council" tax and my dad works in NYC and pays well over 40% in income tax (federal+state+city).
Alex, London, England
Its a shame its so easy for companies to move headquarters abroad, unfotunately its not so easy for poor workers to do the same, otherwise half the country would be moving out to avoid this tax & waste brown administration....
Adrian, Belfast, Northern Ireland
The whingeing and whining at the Chancellors decisions wont change the basic fact,that Allistar Darling is a highly capable wise Chancellor...............................Soup kitchens in the streets would not be out of the question if Osborne ever attained such a position
Eric, Southwick, England
Can Labour make another u-turn, lower all taxes to pre 1997 levels and can I have full reinstatement of my personnel pension contributions. Labour are so Greedy and wasteful.
steve tea, manchester, cheshire
What is the problem? This is NuLab, they need all the monies from the rich to make the rich richer and poor poorer, that means taking monies from any source, including innovations. People have to be controlled and managed, that is why UK voted for and will continue to vote for NuLab. Just pay up!
YT, London, UK
People who complain about UK policies may not know that in USA companies pay far more tax. They pay tax even if they re-locate their HQs. Every US citizen and resident has to keep filing and paying taxes for life even if they move abroad and have not lived there for 50 yrs! They call it Freedom!
Don W., London,
The trouble with socialists is they never know when to stop turning the tax screw. Time and again their own stupidity is their demise.
David Thijm, Stourbridge, UK
Plainly, Labour wish to destroy the economy before handing it back to the tories. They are leaving a number of incendiary devices with long dated fuses.
Will, Lincoln, UK
... and what exactly, is Mr Almostmonobrow Darling's qualifications as far as economics and finance are concerned?
We need a mass overhaul of the political system.
Pete, Cov,
I read with interest the CBI comments on tax but it is not only the CBI that are concerned it is also all who currently live on these shores. Mr Brown says our current situation is due to world issues. It is not the world that has decide on high taxation e.g fuel. The CBI conclusion emigrate
Bambury, Rotherham, UK
We need somebody in power with a grasp of tax policy. Darling and Brown have none. Neither has George Osborne, unfortunately.
Frank Upton, Solihull,
The reason corporations pay tax is that they are granted the same rights as individuals in a court of law. They have individual rights, therefore they have the same responsibilities as an individual- including paying tax . If they don't want to pay tax- then why should they retain those rights?
Miss Dee, Tayside, UK
My US Holding Co. holds my US patents. I am in the US simply because "the City don't do investment". You get prosperity from investment, but the City does not do investment. Particularly into the small high tech start up who wishes NOT to be traded in M&A. Sadly the Treasury still does not "Get It".
Chris Coles, Medstead, Alton, United Kingdom
Big Corpn are no fools. They can see for themselves how Brown is blood sucking us. Add it the "thought that counts" factor - as in - announced intentions toward Big Corp. Trust gone. Broke as broke can be Government exposed in all it's
rancid glory.
General Public exodus..... bled dry!.
Beverley, Bilston, England
We seem to be getting monthly tax changes to the tax structure and tax rates from this Government now. Anyone else getting confused? Perhaps we should extend the smoking ban to the Treasury - then they wouldn't have any 'fag' packets to jot their latest 'policies' on.
Donna Walker, Effingham, England
Yet another government policy that lacks research, testing, and analysis- instead it is simply rolled out. When will the government learn that it has to justify its decisions to not only the populace, but also influential business. This government is yet again damaging Britain's image and status.
Kieran, Somerset, England
Why does anyone in the UK believe that governments care what we, the voters, think about them or their policies. They don't, because we have no choice as to whether to pay them or not. Multinationals are different: they do have a choice. Oh, and they provide lucrative jobs to ex-politicians.
Steve, London, UK
Sara Scherrer - in order to compete with Germany and France or indeed any other country in industrial production requires investment.
The UK and particularly the City don't do investment. We do consumption.
DickW, Aberdeenshire,
And now Governments at last become aware of the extensive powers to corporations of Globalisation. Choose where to pay your staff in the World .. Choose where you pay your tax. This climb down won't stop the exodus it is too cost effective to move, same as with offshoring of jobs.
Joe Postin, Geelong, Australia
So long as Europe and the US refuse to harmonise tax and take control of tax havens the developed world risks falling into decline through corporate greed and blackmail. Confucius he say use the Che method. Impose a 10% rate, reduce expenditure and let the people raise their standard of living
peter fieldman, paris, france
Another embarrassing climbdown. So predictable: Labour knee-jerk response to a headline. Pause for thought. Ramifications considered. U-turn. What a dreadful government.
Roddy Campbell, Christchurch, New Zealand
The whole premise of corporate tax is deeply flawed. Corps. don't pay tax, consumers do. It becomes a cost of production like all other costs. So go ahead and scream for them to pay their fair share (more!). An overall rise in their tax rates will be passed on to you. Be careful what you wish for.
Jim McLaughlin, Calgary, Canada
Alex, London. You for got the working class, the vast majority aslo hate them.
peter reddington, leeds, UK
Eric,
i am going to assume you are being sarcastic. for your sake i really hope you are though there is a sucker born every day.
Alex, London, England
An incredible ATTEMPT at deceit is taking place........the fundemental reality is that the Labour government have the fairest attitude to taxation.................floods of lemming type letters from tory followers simply wont change that reality.................they ALWAYS omit tory policies.
Eric, Southwick , Eric
Its interesting to note the Chair of the panel is Jane Kennedy; a glance of her CV will help to reveal the importance this Government attaches to this discussion process. A career politician with no previous business experience....
Mervyn Ashton, Harrogate,
Gordon Brown is the most miserable incompetent minister of State ever. 11 yrs.constant taxation by stealth and deferment ("the tax increase will come into effect next April"....etc) then squandered by incompetent lazy public officials such as Gorbels Mick, eventually brings workers to exhaustion.
don Lynch, Bristol,
The poor will continue to pay higher taxes so that the rich can continue to leech off them. A sad fact of history, alas.
Brian, Liverpool, UK
Another U turn coming which damages further the idiot Chancellor's reputation. The cupboard is bare and the 10% tax fiasco, the non doms fiasco, now the extention of taxation to offshore co assets shows how desperate to find more revenue the Government is. Short termism causing long term damage.
William A Shuttleworth, Zadar, Croatia
No one has mentioned the INCREASE in the rate of tax for small companies.
Not only did Gordon Brown try to snatch more tax from the poorest 10p taxpayers, at the same time he also put up small companies rate from 19p to 22p.
So we now know Labour attacks the poorest and the hardest working.
MarkS, Leeds,
There is no way you can stop any person or company leaving the UK and shifting their tax residences to another country. A system like the American one is the best you can hope for, which I believe is a one off windfall. After which the golden egg of the annual tax take is gone with the goose
Nick, London, UK
Gordon, like all politicians (?) is critisism-blind. Believe me, he shall continue until ousted. He is highwayman.
alex hewetson, Glasgow, Lanarkshire
Martin,
business's have every right to do that as we are living in a time where business and finance have no borders. every gov needs to ensure a secure environment for business otherwise they will leave and unfortunately Labour is desperate and taking this country down with it.
Alex, London, England
Britain must compete with Germany and France on Industrial Production, not on Tax Gimmicks.Britain will join the Euro Zone. The only question is ; At what price, and when ?The British Public should be spared the misery of this present Government.
Sara Scherrer, Zurich, Switzerland
Hold a second before the baying mob start attacking the government. Why not ask whether large British firms should be allowed to deliberately move HQs abroad to not pay any tax. By doing so we all end up paying more income tax. If the super rich paid tax we could all get a 10% rate cut!!!
Martin Caldwell, London, United Kingdom
Gordron, We the country, business & people, have no more to give. In the good years you took the credit and taxed us to death, your answer to a problem was to throw money at it without a care on its success. Your high risk gamble has failed. Please please leave.
David, Washington, ENGLAND
It is unbeleivable why and how did they manage to destroy super system that for decades was building a top business environment that everybody was benefiting from??? And they choosed very good time when there was recession comming!We will be suffering for times to come.
Slobodan, London, UK
What an extraordinary stupid people Brown and Darling are to think that because they tell us the Revenue service is not there to raise taxes and widen the tax net we are just going to believe them. Of course I believe them totally now and understand I was living under the illusion that the Tax man was there to raise taxes for the government of the day. Well of course being so stupid as to think this I have only one question, If the tax man is not there to raise taxes, widen the tax net or come up with really stupid and crass ways to get peoples money and send big business to tax friendly jurisdictions- What the hell is it there for at all and can we expect it to be scrapped totally in the very near future? Brown thought he could fill Tony Blairs shoes NO CHANCE
Lloyd, London-on route to Dublin, UK
So Marx was right all along. National governments powerless in the face of huge multi-national corporations, forced to shape policy around the interests of big capital at the expense of the mass of people who have to work for a living. Clearly real power lies in the boardrooms not in parliament.
Tony, Liverpool, UK
the reason new labour can claim to have managed the economy well since they came to power is simply that they inherited the machine from Thatcher and just kept it running .. as soon as they start tinkering with the machinery themselves it starts falling to bits !
andy , Lyon, France
labour, it is time for you to go. thank you for making an enormous portion of this country dependent on the welfare state which is now financed through an absurdly high level of taxation. business (now) hates you, the middle class hates you, non-doms hate you...just leave and give us our money back
Alex, London, England
If these measures are 'revenue neutral' and will not raise additional tax.... ermm, then why do it? What's in it for the Government?
I can confidentally predict that someone somewhere will be paying more. Most likely small businesses that aren't part of the select members club.
John Pickworth, Blackpool, UK
Non-doms, 10p tax band, corporate tax - all fiascoes because the policy was made on the hoof to catch a sound bite. The Big Clunking Fist claims expertise in this area, God help us if this were true!
As Alan Sugar might, and the country should, say: 'Gordon, you're fired!'
Chas, Hong Kong,
Laffer curve anyone?
J Smith, Bristol,
This is just another variation on the 10p Tax Band row, isn't it? I doubt they can even remember the original purpose of this latest disgraceful gaffe.
No time is too soon for them to go.
Andrew Waldron, Bournemouth, UK