For many of us, one of our biggest fears is not being able to pay the mortgage or meet other financial commitments should we find ourselves made redundant or unable to work through illness or accident.

While there are a number of ways in which you can protect yourself against loss of income, one of the more controversial forms of cover is payment protection insurance (PPI).

What is PPI?

PPI is designed to cover you if you fall ill, have an accident or lose your job and can't make repayments on loans or credit cards.

How to cut the cost of car insurance

Background

• How to choose travel insurance

• Life insurance explained

• Payment protection insurance explained

• Private health insurance explained

But while it can offer a sense of security, the cover can be overpriced, filled with exclusions and often mis-sold.

For example, policies do not pay out if you are self-employed, and if you do make a claim, the benefit is often little more than the premium paid.

That said, if you do qualify for a payout, the short-term lifeline it offers can help you to survive a financial crisis.

What is MPPI?

Mortgage payment protection insurance (MPPI) policies pay your mortgage for a year - sometimes two years - if you are unable to work because of accident, sickness or redundancy.

However, it is recommended that you consider income protection before opting for MPPI (see below), as income protection pays out for decades. MPPI policies also have many exclusions. For example, you may not be covered for existing medical conditions.

PPI under scrutiny

The consumer group Which? first highlighted the problems associated with PPI a decade ago. Yet when it carried out a mystery shopping exercise last year, it found that consumers were still being "duped" into buying the cover.

It said that people were at risk of unknowingly purchasing the cover because staff at some providers added PPI during the sales process as a matter of course.

Elsewhere last year a number of lenders were fined by the Financial Services Authority (FSA), the City watchdog, for mis-selling. The FSA is conducting its own investigation into whether the sale of PPI conforms with its rules on treating customers fairly.

At the same time, an investigation by the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) exposed sales staff for telling borrowers that the cover was compulsory, or including it in loan quotes without explaining that it was optional.

The OFT referred the PPI sector, including MPPI, to the Competition Commission in February 2007

What progress has been made by the Competition Commission?

The Competition Commission is carrying out its own investigation and has found that lenders are generating revenues of £1,200 on policies that cost as little as £20 to sell.

According to the commission's working paper, PPI is highly profitable and is bolstering lenders' income. Figures show that the total revenue from PPI reached an estimated £2.4 billion in 2006, while profits reached £1.4 billion.

The commission says that these profits have propped up an otherwise loss-making loans market in recent years, but added that the credit card and mortgage markets were less reliant on income from PPI.

It has also said that some loan operations would not be profitable without income from PPI, although it is not due to make a final ruling until later this year.

Check with your lender

If you take out a loan, check whether the quote includes PPI and remember that it is not compulsory. If you don't want it, you can ask the lender to remove it.

Consider a standalone policy

If you do want to take out PPI, it is generally cheaper to buy standalone cover offered by the likes of British Insurance, the broker

Claim a refund

Consumer groups, such as MoneySavingExpert, have started campaigns to encourage borrowers to claim refunds on PPI. Template letters can be downloaded from the website to help you to reclaim the costs associated with the cover.

Consider the alternatives

Before opting for PPI, make sure that you look at the alternatives. For most people, an income protection policy should be the first choice, according to the protection broker Lifesearch. These policies are designed to pay out tax-free replacement income if you are off work through sickness, accident or injury.

However, do not sign up until you have found out what is covered by your employer's sick-pay scheme, as you could be over-insuring yourself.

Also useful is life cover with a good critical-illness policy, which pays out a lump sum if you have a serious illness diagnosed. These two types of cover tend to be sold together, but note that critical-illness cover is a luxury product and should be bought only in addition to income protection if your budget allows.

Make use of the internet when comparing products. Income protection comparison tables can be useful when researching the various options.

Do not buy on price alone

When buying any protection product, price should not be the only consideration. You should also look for the policy that best suits your individual circumstances.

Furthermore, always consult a financial adviser when buying protection insurance, as that is the only way that you can make a complaint if the product you are sold is usuitable for you.

Five news stories

FSA fines Liverpool Victoria £840,000 for mis-selling insurance policies

Competition Commission looks into banks' payment protection

FSA attacked over PPI comparison table

Fight for your PPI refunds

Watchdog reveals payment protection profits

Five features

Get thousands back from your bank

So you want to pile on pounds?

Don't waste money on futile insurance policies, warns consumer body

Five ways the banks fleece us

Ten things: Payment Protection Insurance

Five websites

Which?

MoneySavingExpert

Lifesearch

Office of Fair Trading (OFT)

Competition Commission