Britain’s most senior judge is being tipped to take over as head of the first
supreme court in what will trigger a major reshuffle of top judicial posts.
Recruitment to the new post is now under way, and the hot favourite is Lord
Phillips of Worth Matravers, who is currently Lord Chief Justice. A decision
is expected by May.
Lord Phillips, who is popular with judges and ministers and regarded as a
moderniser, is predicted to become senior law lord when Lord Bingham of
Cornhill steps down this year. That in turn would lead to him becoming
president of the new supreme court when it comes into being in autumn next
year, a new, more high-profile role than that occupied by Lord Bingham.
In autumn 2009 the 12 law lords are expected to move out of their obscure
corridor in the House of Lords, across Parliament Square and into what was
Middlesex Guildhall Crown Court, which is presently being refurbished.
The law lords will no longer be called law lords but have another title,
probably justices of the supreme court. When the new court opens, it will
make the country’s highest court far more visible than ever its predecessor
was. The public will be encouraged to visit and some elements, probably
openings of appeals and the handing-down of judgments, could be televised.
If Lord Phillips is chosen, it would clear the way for a new appointment to
the other top judicial post of Lord Chief Justice, prompting a spate of
further promotions.
The selection of the new president coincides with the departure of three law
lords – Lord Hoffmann, Lord Scott of Foscote and Lord Carswell – meaning
that one third of the court will be replaced, with the potential for a shift
in political and social balance.
Lord Bingham, who has to step down in July when he turns 75, told The Times:
“If you want to make the point that this [the law lords] is an important
pillar of the constitution, there is no place, physically or geographically,
that would be better.”
For the first time, the senior law lord is being chosen through modern
selection procedures in which candidates may have to submit applications and
attend interviews. Lord Bingham is chairing the panel, which includes Lord
Hoffmann, the second senior law lord, and a representative of each of the
Judicial Appointments Commissions of England and Wales, Scotland and
Northern Ireland.
