Ben Webster, Transport Correspondent
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
British Airways attempted to conceal how many bags it was losing after discovering that it had come bottom of an industry league table, The Times has learnt.
The airline contacted its trade body, the Association of European Airlines (AEA), and ordered it not to announce the results of its quarterly survey of baggage delays and punctuality.
The air passenger watchdog said it was outrageous for BA to try to hide the truth from passengers and said that European legislation was needed to force all airlines to produce monthly performance reports.
In April, May and June, BA recorded its worst missing-baggage figures for at least five years, losing one bag for every 36 passengers carried. Its performance was almost twice as bad as the European industry average of one lost bag for every 63 passengers.
So many bags accumulated at Heathrow after missing their flights that BA hired a fleet of lorries to take them by road to Milan, where they spent several more days being sorted. Many passengers were left without their bags for their entire holiday and some had to wait for more than four weeks to have their luggage returned.
The survey also showed that BA was among the worst-performing airlines for punctuality, with almost a third of flights departing late. Only three, much smaller, airlines of the 28 in the AEA survey scored lower.
A senior BA manager contacted the AEA and said that the airline was very concerned by the damage that the previous quarterly surveys had done to its reputation. These surveys had received widespread media coverage and had resulted in BA being criticised strongly by passenger groups. The manager told the AEA to stop its normal practice of issuing a press release to announce that the survey results were available.
He also said that BA wanted the figures to be placed on an obscure part of the AEA website, where they would be difficult to find.
An AEA source said that it felt very uncomfortable about concealing the figures in this way, but did not want to upset such a powerful member airline. The AEA relies heavily on BA’s expertise when dealing with the European Commission and other authorities. The AEA source said: “BA said it did not want us to draw attention to these figures because they were embarrassing. It was the only airline to raise this concern.”
Simon Evans, the chief executive of the Air Transport Users Council, said: “It is outrageous and reprehensible for an airline to hide information in this way simply because it does not compare well with its peers. It takes away the whole integrity and transparency of the system.”
He said that the AEA had only started to publish the figures in 2003 because it realised that, if it did not reveal them voluntarily, the European Commission would compel its members to do so. Mr Evans added: “We and others have been calling for some time for airlines to be required to report these figures so that they can be published in a very public way.”
A spokesman for Lufthansa, another senior AEA member, said: “We would never seek to hide these figures. We accept that sometimes we will be seen to do badly but you can’t always have the sunny side of life.”
A BA spokesman initially denied that the airline had tried to suppress the figures. He said: “It’s got nothing to do with us whatsoever.” BA later admitted it had made a complaint to the AEA about the survey because it was incomplete. The airline claimed that some member airlines, including Virgin Atlantic and bmi, had failed to report how many bags they had lost.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I wanted to travel from Glasgow to HTW for interview in Uxbridge at 12.00. I arrived at Glasgow Airport 2 1/2 hours before the flight time. This is in 1999, before all the fuss about security. On check-in I was told that the outward from Glasgow is delayed because the plane that I was to travel on had NOT left HTW. So they couldn't give me anytime when I will be on the flight. The next flight was at 11.15. I was told by the BA customer desk that if I wanted to get to HTW by 11.00 I should either travel on 11.15 flight to arrive at 12.15 or catch the 9.30 to GTW and catch the inter-airport coach. I decided to do the later. At GTW I was told by BA customer desk that I have no chance by coach to getting to HTW by 1.00. The best choice was to travel by rail across London to Uxbridge. I did. I arrived for interview at 2.30 pm. I didn't get the job. Should I trust British Airways? BA's arrogance stems from days of Lord King. Once BA is bought by Middles easterns it will alright.
K V, MK,
Referring to the comment above, I don't know what "dish-cloth uniforms" have to do with lost bags....
Susan Zimmermann, Zurich, Switzerland
What with BA and BAA it's amazing anyone would ever want to fly through Heathrow. That combination has to be in the lower decile of Industry performance worldwide
David Jenkins, Weybridge, UK
Actions always speak louder than words! BA should stop whining and invest to clean up their own act to improve operational performance. As for Heathrow, it will continue to be the airport of last choice until BAA takes real action, visible to passengers, instead of making excuses in press releases and HM Government adopts the same carry-on rules as the rest of the civilized world.
JB, Seattle, USA
None of this is any surprise. BA has lied and cheated its way through business for many years, smeared its competitors and detractors and treated its passengers with contempt.
BA lost my bags coming back from a business trip to India a few years ago. When I expressed outrage they just laughed at me and told me "that's what your insurance is for. Next...."
Maurice, London, UK
BA are a national disgrace and should be brought to account. My wife and I spent four weeks in the USA June/July. Only two aspects of the holiday were unsatisfactory: the journey to Seattle when BA lost my wife's luggage; and the journey back to Edinburgh when the shambles of a security scare, BA and BAA required us to hire a car and drive to home from Heathrow after 32 hours withour sleep! It's now two months and BA has still not found our baggage and a month since both the Chief Executive and the Customer Services Manage have not responded to recorded delivery letters and claims.
T David Pattison, Edinburgh, UK
Poor BA, they sure are getting a bashing at the moment! The baggage issue will continue for all airlines until they start investing in available high tech systems that I believe would cost around US$0.05 per passenger, per bag. The airport operator would also have to contribute but it seems that neither airline or airport operator are willing to move forward on such a project.
It reminds me of ticket fraud, credit card fraud and so forth. Solutions are and have been available but for whatever reason nobody wants to make the initial investment or perhaps remove control and give it to the consumer.
As for Passenger security, well here again a minor change in procedures and investment in high tech equipment would speed up throughput and allow the airlines to do what they best that is moving people from A to B.
A change in flight control systems could resolve more than half the current flight delays and save millions of gallons of fuel but nobody, it seems, wants to make the investment.
Melvyn Simson, Sipson, Middlesex, UK
What a sad and pathetic outfit BA is!
Truly in line with our national behaviour and helping us to become the laughing stock of the world !
Dudley Wood, Wilby , England
I never fly BA if I can avoid it. BA is appalling in every respect and I have now had so many bad experiences that I would rather pay more to travel with a different airline. Even the staff have been totally demoralised (you can see this in their customer service attitude) and who can blame them having to put up with the idiots in charge! And what is with those dish-cloth uniforms - awful, awful, awful. Just look at Singapore airlines, miles ahead in every respect.
TB, Staffs,
At least BA play the game - Virgin presumably have an equally bad record and choose to bury the information, rather than declare it to the AEA
Neil Marshall, Cambridge, UK
Sinclair, it is very likely the case that the poor baggage numbers are directly attributable to BAA who handle BA's bags at Heathrow. BA actually has little influence over the poor service provided by the BAA as a monopoly supplier.
Ken Liddell, Ampthill, England
This is yet another reason to avoid both Heathrow and BA. I say this with the benefit of hindsight.
Andrew Evans, Raymond, USA, Maine
Unfortunately many people have had poor experieneces as a result of low-quality yet unavoidable baggage handling partnerships, which plague all airlines. Despite the opinions of some members of the air travelling public, all airlines suffer from the same problems, and the narrow-minded and inexcusable scape-goating of one airline, time after time, is neither productive nor a true representation of the domestic or global airline industry as a whole.
Thomas Smith, Windsor, Berkshire, England
I flew BA to Dubai in February. I arrived on the 12th. My bag turned up on the 16th -- by which time I was in Abu Dhabi. And they could not possibly have cared less. They knew where the bag was before we landed -- they were actually able to tell me just as we started our descent that my bag had not accompanied me -- but they still couldn't get it to me and their lack of concern, then or at any subsequent point, was stunning. It was my problem, it wasn't theirs and they didn't give a stuff. It was not the first time BA had done this to me -- but it was the last. They have joined Korean, Saudi and a small handful of others on my personal list of AIRLINES I WILL NOT FLY.
(Go Emirates to Dubai. Go Etihad to Abu Dhabi. Go Qatar to Doha. If you're an habitual BA-er, you'll be astounded by how good air travel can be with an airline that takes care of its passengers).
John Lynch, Whittington, UK
Over the past 14 months I have traveled 3 times with BA from mexico to the netherlands for 2 week visits. On al three occasions BA managed to lose my suitcase. At least the first time they had the decency to offer me some compensation (I think 100 US) but the next times they just shoved some toiletries in my hands...
Simon Schaap, Queretaro, Mexico
And BA have the cheek to accuse the BAA of poor service! There is now no integrity within BA and no leadership to put things right.
Sinclair Stevenson, Bucharest, Romania
Money is the motivation here and not service. Remember, they made better then expected profits. They will action if their profits suffer!
Rob, Brum, UK
"bagage handlers loose 1/36 bags"?
Easy ...these guys are Union Members, and couldn't care less.
Tony J, Swanage, UK
It is reported elsewhere today that BA sell our luggage at an auction house in London.
Why are they allowed to continue trading?
Why have the Directors and senior managers of BA not yet been arrested for fraud, deception and theft?
Bob Brown, Irvine, USA, CA
Well, if BA was motivated to cover up the facts because of a "concern for its reputation," then it didn't need to bother: among regular business travelers, BA's reputation is already shot. Not too many of us will be surprised that BA finished at the bottom of the league tables in terms of delays and lost luggage. In fact, 1/3 of flights delayed and 1 of 36 bags lost seem a bit rosy compared to my personal experiences with BA.
H Juneja, London, England
BA's baggage losses are appalling. How can you "loose" 1 in 36 ?
I suggest the problem is the baggage handlers are too busy thieving to do the job properly and that BA chooses to do nothing about it ? Let's face it, there is little incentive for BA to do so, the compensation for "lost" baggage is pitiful and the true cost falls on passengers and insurers rather than BA.
jasper, chelmsford,
BA lost my bag on the way to Dubai last summer and the number given to me at Dubai airport they did not answer for days and when I finally got through the gentlemen informed me that they where so busy trying to sort out their baggage mess that they had stopped answering the phone. I dont use this airline any more - Etihad and Emirates much better - their movie systems work - and they go to Manchester and Birmingham which avoids the Heathrow problem.
Sean Reid, Dubai, UAE
We are Brits residing in South Africa and have recently returned from a holiday to the UK and Egypt flying Business Class with B A. We spent 8 days in the UK and then on 2nd July 07 we flew to Egypt for a 5 day Nile Cruise and 3 days in Cairo. Our 3 suitcases went missing on transfer through Heathrow and we eventually received 2 cases in Cairo on the 8th July 07 only 24hrs before we flew back to Johannesburg.We spent 5 days in 40 degrees C dressed in our travel clothes and "Egypt" t.shirts with limited toiletries, there being no availability to purchase any decent clothes on route. This spoilt our holiday, of course, as most of our time was spent trying to trace our bags.Our tour agents could not contact London; either getting an engaged tone or a message saying BA had a backlog and to call back later. Our final case arrived in Johannesburg 14 days late.We regularly fly to the UK and of the last 4 flights with BA our baggage has been delayed on 3 occasions.
Ann Goodman, Johannesburg, South Africa
We are a family of four who travelled from the caribbean, where we live to Sweden where we have relatives for our much earned vacation.
We travelled with BA.
Our eight peices of luggage never showed up. Five weeks later we have spent literally hours on the phone to BA in London, Ba's agents in Denmark, Sweden and now Milan in Italy, trying to trace our lost luggage. We don't speak Italian and their English is not much better.
When asked if they could contact the various luggage agents due to the language barriers, we were advised that if we wanted our luggage back we must deal with these agents ourselves since BA are too busy!
With an attitude like that they deserve to be shamed.
Helen williamson, Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands