Patrick Hosking
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
Northern Rock is giving disgraced former chief executive Adam Applegarth a £760,000 pay-off, a £346,000 pension top-up and continuing to honour his cut-price staff mortgage.
The pay-off is much larger than the sum foreshadowed in December, when sources close to the bank insisted Mr Applegarth would get less than six months' pay.
Rock revealed today that it had plunged to a £167.6 million loss last year, compared with a profit of £627 million in 2006, because of the exceptional costs of the strategic review and write-offs on mortgages and unsecured loans.
New chairman Ron Sandler also warned that he expected the bank to continue to make losses for the next three years before breaking even in 2011.
The Rock report also details that:
The extent of the flight by depositors during and after the run last September was revealed for the first time: net outflow of funds was £12.2 billion.
Bryan Sanderson, who was appointed chairman on 19 October and stood down to make way for Mr Sandler last month, will be allowed to keep his £315,000 fee and up to £85,000 for office costs.
And Paul Thompson, who was heading a company-preferred buy-out vehicle for Rock, was paid £100,000 for his services as a non-executive director from 17 January to 22 February - for five weeks' work.
Mr Applegarth, who was responsible for devising and implementing the bank's disastrously flawed strategy, is being paid the golden goodbye in 12 monthly instalments of £63,000, according to the annual report published today.
The value of his pension pot increased by £346,000 last year, the annual report also reveals, and now stands at £2.6 million. The accrued pension entitlement is £305,000 a year.
Mr Applegarth, 45, will also continue to enjoy a concessionary staff interest rate on £75,000 of his mortgage from the bank, Rock said, without disclosing the precise terms.
The pay-off is equivalent to a year's base pay for Mr Applegarth, who finally left in December after announcing plans to step down in November. He had run the bank for the previous six years.
Mr Applegarth has in the past refused to shoulder the blame for Rock's flawed over-dependence on wholesale funding and its over-aggressive expansion of its mortgage book. Last October he told MPs the collapse was the fault of the Bank of England, which failed to approve a potential rescue bid from Lloyds TSB.
Today, the bank admitted to deteriorating quality of its loanbook, with mortgage arrears growing, though still low by industry standards, and bad debts on the £8 billion unsecured loanbook worsening more sharply.
However, there was one glimmer of good news for taxpayers, who are in effect underwriting the £100 billion of Rock liabilities. Bank of England loans to Rock, which stood at £26.9 billion on 31 December, have since been reduced to £24 billion. Rock said it expected to completely repay Bank of England debt by 2010 and to no longer need the Treasury guarantee by 2011.
Mr Sandler said, "Looking ahead we have developed a business plan that we believe will help drive the bank back towards profitability and ensure it has a sustainable future and remains an important employer in the North East."
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Alistairs Solicitors, South West, UK. What about breach of contract - 'ordinary' people are regularly sacked for gross incompetence. Let him bring an action for unfair dismissal if he isn't happy with the decision.
Clint, Brighton, UK
Hasn't the release of this news come a day early??
Tom, Reading,
What ever happened to "Payment by Results" ?
Ken Futter, Swindon,
The solution is easy : Mr Applegarth should be given another job immediately.
john o'bacon, elmstead, uk
Well, we're all mad as hell, here. What are we going to do - carry on whinging? What we need is to import a French trade union official to organise a march on Westminster and the City, with banners, And tents. And we don't move unless the police ask us to. And the government would be so embarrassed they would give us what we want. And we all want a million quid if we lose our jobs, right?
john problem, winchester, uk
Britain has always excelled at rewarding failure, that is why they have the politicians that they have today.
Peter Fordham, Pego, Spain
As we are all shareholders now surely something can be done to stop this travesty, even if it means changing the law to do it.
Nobody can justify this.
warren, hastings,
Look! I've told you before.
If you want to attract the best executives you have to pay top dollar.
What is the problem?
R Bingham, Lauzun, France
Are we the only country to reward failure? Any chance of a job for me where I can mess things up and still walk away with money most people find it hard to earn in 10 years?
V Tan, London,
It may be offensive but not as offensive as the timing of Applegarth's sale of millions of pounds worth of NR shares before they collapsed. I bet within a year this weasel will have another top job, possibly working for the increasingly desperate Gordon Brown as an economic adviser.
Neil McF, Southampton, England
Applegarth won't accept responsibility for the Banks failure but as always, with executives today, accepted the yearly bonus and high pay for dodgy lending strategy that paid handsomely for the last few years.
He is hardly likely to rush out to find paid employment if his bounty for failure is paying out at £63000 a month!
David Thijm, Stourbridge, UK
It may be offensive but not as offensive as the timing of Applegarth's sale of millions of pounds worth of NR shares before they collapsed. I bet within a year this weasel will have another top job, possibly working for the increasingly desperate Gordon Brown as an economic adviser.
Neil McF, Southampton, England
More than most people earn in a lifetime!
Michael, London,
This disgraceful £760,000 payout also demonstrates extreme and continuing incompetence, even naivete on the part of this Government . Particularly in its dealings with the City and Banking.
The payout will be seen by the City as a benchmark payment for failure, approved by and sanctioned by the Government.
Equally Government approval to continuance of what are grossly excessive - but clearly defective incentive payment systems
The Government owns (but clearly cannot effectively manage or control), the wreck of the Northern Rock Bank.
Notwithstanding any amount of political rhetoric, this sort of behaviour can never be accepted as either common sense or proper use of Taxpayers funds.
Keith O, Croydon, UK
I entirely agree with John from London. Just one additional point, as the the bank has now been nationalised, the decision to pay this man must have been approved by the government.
One more reason not to vote Labout next time!
Ken, Orpington, Kent, UK
Frankly speaking, this is just typical of the contempt our so-called betters hold us ordinary people in! How on Earth can any payment be justified to this total incompetent!
All I can say is:
"Come the revolution we'll need a very long wall and an awful lot of bullets!".
Clive Dudley, Plymouth, England
Would Northern Rock have been rescued by the government if it wasn't slap bang in the middle of loads of Nulaber-voting constituencies?
Cheer up, everybody, this is just another cost to be born by you all as the price of having a Socialist government.
You know what to do at the next election now, surely ???
Either that or, like me, get out while you can.
Jon Leigh, Southern, France
now you see why the great isn't in britain anymore as you see, we are mainly known as the UK but we are wimps we allow the banking institutions to make themselves ric her at our expense, like the unlawful c harges banks charge on c omputer generated letters to us, when we get charged for going overdrawn massive sums of £35 pounds, when the sum overdrawn is usually between £1-50 at most, on 95% of times, plus the interest that then generates is out of proportion to the whole amount, use the financ ial ombudsman association they may be able to get the bank to pay back as they did for me, we all hav e to fight the cooperate world, as thats what is making the money which stays among the rich people, Stand up for your rights.
jonathan rose, GT Torrington, devonshire
If my memory serves me correctly Johnson Matthey had a bank which ran into trouble and had to be taken over by the Bank of England. Its directors were then sent packing without so much as a penny piece of compensation. Why hasn't this happened at NR?
Chris, Birmingham,
Disgraceful, outrageous and symptomatic of much that wrong with this country - reward incompetence and failure, and turn a blind eye to corruption while thousands of hard-working staff are likely to made redundant for no fault of their own! No wonder UK plc is going down the tubes.
It stinks and so does any government that allows travesties like this to continually happen.
Oxford Don, Oxford, UK
The Sanctity of Contract?
This man had a Directors Service Contract with a year's notice. Do we or do we not protect the sanctity of contract?
Alistairs Solicitors, South West, UK
I for one am applying for the job. I have no experience what so ever in the finacial market but for that kind of money i'll give it a go, and quite frankly who cares if I manage to make an even more of a gargantuan cock-up as Mr applegate, as I can only assume I would receive an even more lucrative payout.
Sam Matthews, Leeds,
I think the Financial Services Authority (FSA) should be interested in this case under the recent introduction of the Treating Customers Fairly rules better known as TCF in the financial services industry. Clearly, other customers are not now being treated fairly as preferential loan treatment is being awarded to an ex director of the business. if that isn't abusing the rules then i don't know what is.
Paul Farrant, Sevenoaks, Kent
Mr Applegarth can I have my money back please?
kirk, Rotherham, UK
Nothing will ever change with these disgusting golden handshakes no matter what the ordinary man in the street says.
The people who are in a position to change it are on a similar gravy train !!!!!
As an example, everyone in this country complains about buying and selling a house but the system still remains.
philip, Andover, England
This man should be on a criminal charge not a 3/4m payoff for his reckless and greed driven behaviour. How he can have the bare faced cheek to blame the BoE for the failure of his business model defies belief.
Banking is the only business on the planet which gets away with privatising profits and nationalising losses. He and these city jokers knew the debt bubble would burst eventually on the back of CDOs and sub prime but why would they care? As the rewards for the volume of business they have put through the books for the last 10 years has meant they they and their offspring are made for generations.
Frankly this is disgusting. If the British population wasn't such a docile apathetic mass this man would be swinging by his Versace tie from the nearest lamp post!
John, London, England
An utter disgrace. Have the new NR management taken leave of their sences?
Roger Sherrin, Sherborne , Dorset
The FSA could fine him £760,00?
SH, Leeds, UK
The world is upside-down. You do a good job you get redundant: «sorry mate, last in first out». You blow up millions in smoke You get a cash-prize like this.
Talk about meritocracy...
Rui, Lisbon,
Disgraced and disgraceful. I presume Mr Applegarth will be needing the money, as it may be hard for him to find any kind of meaningful employment in the years to come. I hope he invests the money wisely, rather than with some sort of "Mickey Mouse" financial institution.
peter koeb, al jezur, portugal
£760,000,, dont worry, he cant even buy a 2 bed falt for that now.
Oliver , Reading, UK
Talk about adding insult to injury!
Don Basilio, Cambridge, UK
Northern Rock is behaving no differently to any other major company - incompetent staff would get 1 months salary, incompetent directors a year plus pension rights. Shareholders (in this case taxpayers) should question companies' renumeration policies.
Steve, London, UK
It has been normal in this country to pay them well that would destroy everything...
satan has the whole world deceived.
Hugh E Torrance, London, England
The jobs people must look for are bankers and polititians.
adam, Durham, uk
Even if, as Mr Appleyard says, the Bank of England is at fault for not allowing Lloyds/TSB to buy NR, it was still the fault of Mr Appleyard that NR was in the position that it was, otherwise nobody would have had to rescue it. Mind you, it is a common theme in business, both public and private, that in the good times it is down to the chairman and directors, in the bad times it's always somebody elses fault. The trouble is the people that really suffer are the staff, who had no say in anything.
David Leslie, Perth, Scotland
A complete and utter bloody disgrace. through his abysmal mismanagement the British taxpayer has had to acquire a 100billion, that's right 100billion, white elephant. Not only should this incompetent swine get nothing, his assets should be sequestered and he should be flayed. What he and his cohorts did is nothing short of a crime. They frankly should go to jail.
Billy Barnett, HK,
Someone should put a curse on the money given to these Chief Executives, instead of everyone simply accepting that awarding them vast sums of money for failure is justified. No doubt justice will catch up with them all in due time....
Bob B, Fareham, Hampshire
Money goes to money.If you deliver you get massive payouts,if you FAIL to deliver you get massive payouts.What's the difference?Corrupt ,immoral and ridiculous.
john, shrewsbury, uk
What an interesting remuneration package. I wonder what sort of settlement other employees of the Rock, who had no control over the collapse, got when there services were dispensed with.
Maybe it is time that senior directors put as much effort into running the company as they put into securing their remuneration packages even when they fail.
tony wood, London, UK
Surely NR is having a laugh?!?!?!
This is simply unbelievable - the head-honcho who presided over the bank's demise is given this kind of money, while NR staff are soon to be fired, many of NR's mortgage customers find themselves in dire straights, & the tax payer is picking up the pieces.... If I had caused this much disaster to my company, I would have been hung, drawn & quartered. This is obscene!
Ash, Tunbridge Wells,
Six years ago after the bursting of the dotcom bubble and Enron scandal I advocated regulating the financial markets and bringing in more stringent controls on the excessive remuneration packages of senior financial and corporate managers.
Well, here we are again. The climate of corporate greed which has become endemic in Western corporate society persists, rewarding failure as well as success.
The present financial crisis has demonstrated the urgent need for a redistribution of wealth in the financial and business community.
The vast sums disappearing into the pockets of a minority who can't and/or won't spend it does not make economic sense. Neither does giving them favourable tax treatment or putting up the price of council tax, energy and transport, which hurts the majority of the population.
It is time to spread wealth around so that the middle class and poor can increase their purchasing power and thus generate economic growth
peter fieldman, paris, france
How can they justify these payments when they are being supported by the taxpayer. nany NR shareholders must view this with dismay.
Ian Ashton, Cornwall,
No banker ever seems to suffer a financial penalty, regardless of how incompetent or corrupt they are. I expect that even if all the savers had lost their money he would still be walking away with a fortune. Shameful.
Can I become a banker please?
David, St Albans, UK
Ridiculous. Utterley ridiculous that any organisation should reward incompetence. The logic behind paying very high salaries and bonus to execs is that "if you want the best then you pay more". NR appears to reward the worst performing execs and throws this logic out the window
Mark Wharton, Wantage, UK
what a sick joke.760000 quid for being incompetent banks need nationalizing now.
mike, coventry, U.K.