Martin Waller
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Sterling rose against the dollar in early trading today, despite forecasts by George Osborne, the Shadow Chancellor, that higher government borrowing could lead to a run on the currency.
The pound recovered to $1.5007 by Monday afternoon, after closing at $1.4855 on Friday before Mr Osborne's comments emerged in The Times that sterling was heading for "a collapse" if Gordon Brown attempted to borrow his way out of recession. Against the pound, the euro was unchanged at 0.857.
Mr Osborne later defended his remarks against accusations that he was talking down sterling. "My job... is to tell the British people the truth about the British economy," he said, in a TV interview.
Lord Mandelson, the Business Secretary, today piled further pressure on the Shadow Chancellor by accusing him of being "irresponsible and reckless" in his comments about the pound.
The peer told the BBC's Today programme: "We haven’t heard an alternative from the Conservatives. If you exclude further borrowing all you’re left with is sitting on your hands, as the Conservatives seem to be, doing nothing about it.
"Osborne was trying to undermine the confidence of markets, undermine the confidence of traders. It was reckless and irresponsible…and quite contradictory. Their policies change every week."
In his interview on Saturday, Mr Osborne highlighted a 30-per cent fall in value of the pound over recent months against a basket of currencies, and said that Government policies were creating the "danger of having a proper sterling collapse, a run on the pound".
He was accused of ignoring a convention that senior politicians do not "talk down the pound" - but yesterday dismissed the idea that he would be to blame for any further falls
"What the markets are doing (is) looking at the economic fundamentals. They are not looking at what politicians - be it myself or indeed any other politicians - are saying. These are hard-headed market operators," he said.
"They are looking at the fundamentals and they are making a judgment about the British economy. They are making a judgment that we are worse placed than other economies - the US and some other European countries."
Speaking at the G20 summit in Washington, where world leaders committed themselves to a recovery "route map" involving pumping more money into their economies, Gordon Brown weighed in on the criticism of the Shadow Chancellor, saying that he "regretted the partisan talk from the Opposition".
"I believe that at a time when nations are coming together all over the world to deal with these problems, I think people are looking to politicians to be responsible and to show leadership," he said.
Alistair Darling, the Chancellor, also told Sky News: "All I would say is this, that a few weeks ago the Tories offered a bipartisan approach, now that has clearly gone to the wind."
Mr Osborne’s position is also considered to have been weakened by a lack of vocal support from David Cameron. The Shadow Chancellor was also forced to dismiss suggestions that his authority had been undermined because Mr Cameron had called in Oliver Letwin, his predecessor, to draw up potential government spending cuts.
Meanwhile, a significant party donor, the retail millionaire Lord Kalms, called for Mr Osborne to be replaced with a "heavyweight" figure.
But the Shadow Business Secretary, Alan Duncan, rallied around his frontbench colleague, saying he was "absolutely right" to raise the danger of a run on sterling. "I’d rather have George Osborne telling the truth than Gordon Brown charging around the world on a journey of deceit," he said.
Articles from our sister site WSJ.com:
You may be asked to subscribe to read certain articles
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Using printing press to print more money to bail evreybody out against the decreasing productivy , will mean that the £ will debase and become less worthy. The same goes for the Euro & Dollar ...they are all fiat ( no value ) money. They are technically worthless. We just lost 25% of our savings
zeci, Athens, Greece
Currency speculators move money around all the time, so £ will go up & down. But the underlying trend is down because of an excessive 1.5% base rate cut; a weak UK economy; Brown saying that rates must reduce again (I thought that was the BoE's decision?); & Brown spinning his unfunded tax cuts.
David, London, UK
& Mandy could never be accused of being irresponsible or reckless of course!
Ian Stabb, South Brent, England
Brown is the car driver who causes a car crash. Now he argues that the only way out of the car crash is to pay everyone in the country a fiscal stimulus to get the car moving again.
What happens if the country just takes the tax cut next week and does not spend it? The car just has more debt.
Frank Keegan, Alderley Edge,
Is it when the pound is equal to the Euro in value, we will join the Euro Currency? Is it being deliberately devalued to acheive this?
Matt Jeary, London, UK
Why dont we help Business by charging the Banks and Financial institutes 50% Corporation Tax on their profits until they pay back the money?
Matt Jeary, London, UK
How can you believe anything that Mandleson says.....
Phil, Preston,
The pound has hopefully found its lowest point mostly caused by media hype and the doom and gloom brigade. UK is of course showing its imported more than its exported of which relates to a devalue of currency, but its my guess that hype has brought it down to a level lower than it should be.
Bob Johnson-Perkins, dumaguete , philippines
Every time Gideon Osborne opens his mouth, Labour's opinion poll ratings rise. Keep up the good work!
GARRY LLOYD, Lowton, Warrington, CHESHIRE
I have voted Labour all my life, but never again. Well done, Mr. Osbourne, for speaking out honestly, instead of the rubbish spouted by the Brown and Darling comedy team, who have lost any credibility they ever had. The only thing they do well is sulk. Keep it up, Mr. Osbourne. We need you.
R. Cleeve, Eastbourne, UK
Osborne is right to state clearly that the markets expect a frank admission that increased borrowing will be paid for in 2/3 years by higher income tax rates than we would otherwise have had. Labour, however, have not wanted to state that clearly - since they are trying to buy votes.
Stevie, Bagshot,
Black wednesday 1992, Tories put interest rates to 15% which did nothing to stop a run on the pound, however, it did create the Tories third home grown recession in 18 years, and millions lost their jobs and their homes, Happy Days
Nig , Blackwood, Wales
I'd hardly call this a rebound! Exactly one year ago I received a pension payment in sterling and deposited it at 5% in Barclays. Today, after a year of interest and monthly pension cheques my cash is worth less in Euros than it was last October.
Stuart Dickson, Palma, Mallorca, Spain
A little bit of news for Mr Osborne, 'we know the state of the British economy', what you are supposed to do is to offer an alternative policy for improving it, but the Tory front bench is not very good at policy.
Stuart Gerrard, Derby, UK
Will someone please explain to me why every man and his dog are saying that we in the IK are going to have the worst recession of all the major developed nations and why Gordon Brown is saying the exact opposite? Both can't be right.
Bob Crozier, Larbert, Scotland
Time for Labour to show us a plan. How much will taxes go up and for how long. If you give a person dying of starvation a slice of bread, they will be grateful - even if you caused their starvation and they will die anyway. At least the Tories have said they will pay for this by reducing the State
Narni, Brighton, UK
Osbourne has had to be dragged off of his high hobbyhorse on more than one occasion,,,,,this man does a lot negative daily drivel but..seems to belong to the MAGICWAND strategy regarding any specific plans,,,,,his haughty arrogant manner will be held to account by the electrate
Eric, Southwick, England
Another "Times" non-story. This used to be a serious newspaper until Times Corp'n got hold of it and introduced "The View from Rupert".
The Basics:
Osborne has told the truth - and Labour don't like it.
Roger, Sheffield, UK
When George Osborne said it was his duty to tell the truth about the economy, I fell about laughing. As always, the truth is highly selective and is only told by politicians when it suits them. When David Cameron visited Wales, he said it had some great universities; pity he did not tell the truth!
Trevor Mayes, Llandysul, Wales
What barefaced cheek for Peter Mandelson to accuse others of changing their policies from week to week, when his Government has abandoned every principle of economic management that it has ever championed - from fiscal prudence to the independent conduct of monetary policy.
Throw them out of office
David Meyer, London, UK
Osborne cannot win , if he tells the truth about a further sterling devaluation he is branded as a traitor and it will be his fault if the pound falls further, if Sterling recovers Nulabour will say that the markets are provimg Osborne was wrong and that the markets are supporting Brown policy!!
claudebertin, warlingham, uk
To say that the pound "recovered" to $1.4924 this morning is a bit strong. If that constitutes a recovery, I'd hate to hear your definition of "very strong". The truth is that the pound is in dire straights.
Osbourne has simply spoken out with what we are all thinking. We're in a Brown Bust!
Charlotte, London, UK
1) Whether the value of sterling increases or decreases has nothing to do with Osborne.
2) It has everything to do with the activity of the government; hence, why it has been sliding for some time now.
3) It's a bit early in the game for 'haha, we win, you lose, up yours' from dearest Darling.
James David, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
Hello Osbourne? This is Credibility calling ....
Ben P., Robertsbridge, UK
We do not need Osborne but we do need the pound. To save his own scalp he seems ready to undervalue our currency at the very time when we all need to get together to bring our economy and currency back on track. Osborne could never be a Chancellor because he preaches doom and gloom not hope.
bruce, Glasgow, UK
Despite the fact Brown got us into this mess with reckless borrowing by Govt, encouraging people to get into huge levels of debt, useless regulation and acceptong corporate greed, the Tories seem incapable of scoring points. If they can't in these circumstances, they won't win the election.
sam, newcastle,
Trying to get my mind round WHO (?) is talking the pound down - two weeks ago it was Mr King for the Bank of England - then we had the Chancellor doing the same - is it that THEY wanted to talk it down just a bit - like $1.65, and got it wrong, an overshoot to $1.48? So why Osbourne diffferent?
A Sanders, Malton, UK
It is patently obvious that Labour are using the financial crisis as an excuse to borrow heavily in an attempt to buy the general election in 18 months' time. Regrettably the public are probably stupid enough to buy it.
Tony Pegg, Leicester, England
Gordon Brown's management of the economy is now reduced to a crap shoot. He's like a compulsive gambler racking up piles of debt of other people's money chasing his losses. And this from the man who disapproves of supercasinos...
Now it is wrong for the opposition to criticise the government.
G Adlam, Brighton,
Sorry chaps, but the Tories don't seem to have a clue as to how to deal with this issue. At least Labour are trying do something, including getting the other big economies to sign up to a common approach. Doing nothing is not an option. The key is where you put the money you borrow for best return.
Mark Loughran, Kircubbin, N Ireland
No suprise that the £ is rising today. Market bottoms often occur just when wanabe teenage scribblers like George Osbourne seek kudos by telling us what we already know. Better if he were to come up with some original ideas how to tackle instead of excaberating our financial problems.
Anthony Wolff, London, UK
Most currency traders have probably never heard of George Osborne and certainly won't care whether he yelled Buy or Sell from the roof of his house - they look at more fundamental matters - such as the incompetence of the administration and the recklessness of Gordon Brown's actions.
Father Ignatius Brown, Norwich, Norfolk
Now George Osborne has had the courage to speak out against the doom and gloom from Mervyn King and Gordon Brown the markets have responded positively.
John, London,
Is this news? Surely Osborne is only stating the uncomforable situation we are in and that further spending and thus borrowing will only speed further currency falls for the pound. Perhaps people have been asleep and not noticed currency falls have been dramatic for a while now?
jcabell, Newbury, Berkshire
Why is the pound always measure against the dollar to show how many dollars £1 buys, whereas with the euro it's always measured to show how much 1 euro will buy? £1 currently buys 1.22 euros appox, but the way it's usually shown makes it 0.857 euroes to the pound. Very confusing! Why not just use
Chris, Northampton, England
How DARE George Osborne tell the British people the truth about the mess that ZaNu Labour have got the UK into?
What was he thinking? His job is to say nothing and let Brown continue to bribe the voters with their children's money and get re-elected.
Reality check-: recessions cannot be bucked.
Jon Leigh, Southern, France
'Lord Mandelson said that any tax cuts...have to be targeted at sectors of the population that will increase spending. '
This would be the 18-30 age group with disposable income but no household responsibilities i.e no mortgage, Council Tax or utility bills and probably subsided by parents!
m collins, Leeds,
Please do get it into your heads that what the pound does from day to day has nothing to do with George Osbourne. Lord Mandelson may like to tell you that, over a good lunch no doubt, but there is no need to swallow and regurgitate it so gullibly. The real reason lies elsewhere.
AndyC, Rowlands Castle,
You wouldn't put it past Gordon to be frantically supporting sterling this morning to prove osbourne wrong. What is the point of democracy if the ruling party uses all available media outlets to ridicule valid attempts at criticism. There has been no debate in parliament about economic recovery.
rob, ashbourne, uk
Of course, Mandy has never been irresponsible, has he?
His finances, involving mortgages and loans, were always in order, weren't they?
His meetings and outcomes with Deripaska were always totally above board - any massive profits made were purely coincidental.
Why is the EU still investigating?
Padraig, Perth, Australia
Perhaps the market just recognises that whatever George Osbourne says is usually 180 degrees from the truth.
Eric, London,
Tax cuts are such a shot in the dark..
Why dont they really help business and cut VAT and business rates. We would see that saving over night not in a few months. And I am sure it would be cheaper.
Rich, worcester,
Typical labour blaming all their problems on the tories! I just can't believe the media buys into this spin that has been generated ever since Mandy came back. If they carry on like this we will be stuck with these imbeciles for another four years! People open your eyes!!
Hamish, London, UK