Irwin Stelzer
Your last chance to get tickets to Top Gear Live
“THESE are the times that try men’s souls,” wrote Tom Paine in the harsh winter of 1776 in an effort to persuade his countrymen to persist in their war to throw off the British yoke. “Tis surprising to see how rapidly a panic will sometimes run through a country,” added the English-born Paine.
Some 232 years later the chairman of the Federal Reserve Board and the secretary of Treasury find themselves fighting a different sort of panic, while ordinary investors find themselves in soul-trying straits as their net worth declines for the first time in decades.
Fed chairman Ben Bernanke pulled no punches when he gave his semi-annual report to Congress. “Sizeable losses at financial institutions . . . financial headwinds . . . inflation has remained elevated . . . declining house prices, a softening labour market . . . deteriorating performance of sub-prime mortgages . . . turbulence . . . Decline in the . . . value of the dollar.” There’s more, but you get the idea — a Fed chairman who has deployed every weapon at his command and manufactured new ones in his fight to right the economy, and is not certain he has succeeded.
It just might be that Bernanke, with assistance from Treasury secretary Hank Paulson, has been more successful than he dares dream, and that the panic has been contained. Not that we will soon see the boom times that investors remember so fondly, or that homeowners can soon look forward to double-digit annual increases in the value of their homes. But it is possible that the woes that have beset the housing and financial sectors, and the damage inflicted on consumers by rising petrol prices, are about to be contained and mitigated.
Start with housing. Falling prices, inventories of unsold homes, slowing construction and rising repossessions have combined to shake mortgage institutions to their foundations.
But sales of existing homes seem to have stabilised this year at an annual rate of close to 5m units, with gains in the northeast and Midwest offsetting declines in the south and west. Inventories of new single-family homes are down 21% from their 2006 peak. Nationwide, average house prices continue to decline, but whereas in March only two of the 18 markets covered by the much-watched Case-Shiller Index recorded increases, in April prices rose in six regions. And, as Barron’s magazine points out in an article under the title “Home prices are about to bottom”, price figures are biased downward by the overweighting of sales of homes with sub-prime mortgages. Chip Case — the Case of the Case-Shiller Index — believes that homes are now more affordable and that, barring a recession, prices “may well stabilise” and begin to recover by the year end. Barron’s Jonathan Laing concludes that “the scary dive in home prices soon will be over”.
Improvements in housing would, of course, translate into improvements in the banking sector. The immediate intervention of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), protecting up to $100,000 per depositor, prevented panic after the Indy Mac failure, the third largest in American history. Meanwhile, Merrill Lynch announced that it is raising $4.5 billion by selling its stake in Bloomberg and increasing its excess-liquidity pool to record levels; several investment houses reported earnings that, although off from last year, beat the market’s expectations; and shares in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac began to recover some of the ground lost the previous week.
Freddie Mac (a client of mine) and Fannie Mae are government-sponsored enterprises that finance about half the mortgages in America. Despite the slump in their share prices, these enterprises continued doing what the government wants them to do — they kept mortgage money flowing. True, to offset some of the panic caused by declines in their share prices, Paulson and Bernanke decided to make explicit what investors in Freddie and Fannie bonds always knew — these enterprises are too big to be allowed to fail. So this month both were able to borrow money at attractive rates, and to continue business as usual, writing billions in new mortgages.
It is too early to say that all is calm in the financial sector. More bad loans will be written off, several banks are in less than robust health, and the FDIC has already committed 10% of all its funds to Indy Mac depositors, meaning it might have to call on taxpayers for funds if failures become widespread. Many banks still need to raise equity capital.
Finally, there is oil. Students of the impact of oil prices know that the rapidity of an upward movement has as much effect on the economy as the level of prices. We cannot predict the course of prices with any certainty, since this market is cartel-ridden, affected by “resource nationalism” that inhibits new investment, and has other features that can’t be understood by thumbing through a copy of The Wealth of Nations. But it does seem that higher prices are destroying demand at a more rapid rate than economists anticipated, which might, just might, hold back further price increases, or sustain last week’s downturn in crude prices.
Perhaps most important, the flexible American economy so far — and the “so far” is important — seems to be doing better than the troubled housing and financial sectors. “The economy has continued to expand, though at a subdued pace . . . Personal consumption expenditures have advanced at a modest pace . . . generally holding up somewhat better than might have been expected . . . Growth is expected to pick up gradually over the next two years,” said Bernanke. Imports are adding perhaps a full point to GDP, offsetting all or most of the housing-related decline.
And financial markets are being restructured. Paine wisely noted that “panics, in some cases . . . produce as much good as hurt. They bring things and men to light, which otherwise have lain forever undiscovered”. So inept chief executives have found.
There is, then, light at the end of the tunnel. Let’s hope that Larry Lindsey, former economic adviser to President George W Bush, is wrong when he says the light comes from an onrushing train.
Irwin Stelzer is a business adviser and director of economic policy studies at the Hudson Institute
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2008
£44,990
2008
£48,489
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
Some of the finest Apts & Penthouses
Across London
Great Investment, River Views
Luxury properties within exclusive development in
Chislehurst Kent
A new experience in Luxury Living
Multi–Centre
from Only £829pp
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - search houses for sale and rooms and property to rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The so called good news is really very bad news.The increased growth in the economy means that more resources are being consumed. If the planet is to survive we need to decrease economic growth and thus the demand for resouces. The environmental terrorism continues!
Jim Wills, Brisbane, Australia
All this optimism is just to build an even larger house of cards that will feed greed and perpetuate artificial wealth based on shifting sands, only benefiting those who created this slump. For too long we have had smoke and mirrors fueling growth. Prices based on high salary factoring must stop!
Keith, Pontypridd, UK
I prefer "Solvency is entirely a matter of temperament and not of income". Irwin is correct, the world economy is growing. I feel sorry for property investors but in 2009 after our annual pay increases & oil has dropped, we will look back at 2008 and wonder what all the fuss was about.
Mark Boughtwood, Auckland, NZ
Irving Stelzer is defending the American way even when it is now proving to be at fault.Clever ,greedy banks and lenders have overstretched beyond all belief property funding in the US but have managed to unload a lot of the bad debts.Why will not Stelzer admit that the US has caused this disaster?
bill beeby in dover, dover,kent., england
It seems to me that the investor class should be the most optimistic about the economic future of the U.S. The extremes in the mortgage and housing markets have long needed to be worked out. The rapid rise in oil prices may finally lead us to a clean, independent ,and highly efficient energy future.
Tom Martinez, Seattle, WA,
Can we at least now agree that financial institutions are governed by irresponsible, greedy and amoral delinquents who need a strong dose of regulation to teach them manners? We've tried giving them free reign as they asked and they blew it yet again. Or are we just going to mistakes again & again?
John, Limerick City, Ireland
Don't you mean that exports (rather than imports) are adding perhaps a full point to GDP? Please keep on your rose-colored glasses. I agree with your optimism.
Mark Jackson, Scottsdale, AZ, U.S.A.
everyone is worried about removing the symptom, without really addressing the causes.
goodluck
zo, bury st. edmunds, UK
All folks working for the city should be ostricized by friends, family and neighbours unless they share their ill gotten gains.
Glynn, Kingston,
It is always the best policy to see the glass as half full and if you can convince others then you just might create a self fulfilling momentum.
The nagging doubt is whether the US economy retains international confidence. Irwin, no one can say that you are not doing your best on that score.
Marek, London,
We are heading for a future of fundamental environmental truths
There is an execrable link between unsustainable global growth and adverse global climatic change.
Global economic growth must keep pace with a global environmental policy that would allow for long term sustainable adaptations.
Philip Clarkson, Naxxar, MALTA GC
I am confident about American's economy.
Chen, Wuhan, China
yes its the dole office.
michael joseph, cahersiveen.adams towns, madness
If correct this puts a different perspective on the constant doom & gloom stories the press love to push.
There is strong reason to believe that the price of oil has reached tipping point.If so the pressure from investors will be downward not upward.Perhaps the cavalry are over the hill!!
Bob Greenaway, Tamarin, Mauritius
Irwin, when you turn bearish I'll turn bullish. Your bullish propensity has blinkered you to the current wealth destruction. The Credit bubble has popped and the debtors must now do penance for their overleveraged balance sheets.
Simon, Harrogate, UK
If people are concerned about an economy that is STILL growing, what will happen if the inevitable finally happens and the economy shrinks? There is no law that says we have to produce and consume more every year. The environment will put a stop to it anyway sooner or later.
Heinz Geyer, London,
Yes, there's light at the end of the tunnel.
It's on the train that's rushing to annihilate us. US economic problems are and always were real, and have not vanished into thin air; and to the extent America is recovering, it is exporting its difficulties to us.
Easy responses won't save us.
Noel Falconer MEcon, COUIZA, France
Irwin, do you ever foresee bad news or are you just a natural optimist?
anthony, london, england
Irwin conveniently forgets how optimistic he was one year ago. Take it from me: housing will continue to slide for years, and the dollar will lose 30% of its value this year. Derivatives are in the process of destroying the financial fabric, and the damage has only just begun. The rest is fluff.
Mike M., boston,