Economic Outlook: David Smith
Stories and Songs on today's free French CD, with The Times
IF you can keep your head while others are losing theirs, better not shout about it in today’s environment. What would Rudyard Kipling have made of a frenzy that has taken us from the possibility of recession to a rerun of the Great Depression in days?
We should treat talk of another Great Depression with a similar pinch of salt as when it was predicted after the 1998 global financial crisis and the September 11 attacks on America in 2001.
But if those who ignore the lessons of history are condemned to repeat mistakes, nobody knows better than Fed chairman Ben Bernanke the lessons of the Great Depression era - you do not allow the banking system to implode and compound the problem with a protectionist trade war. Even if the historical parallels were appropriate, which I think they are not, the lessons have been learnt.
As an aside, many people think the Great Depression was the source of the observation that, if America sneezes, Britain catches a cold. That was not the case. America’s gross domestic product (GDP) fell by about a third from 1929 to 1932, while Britain’s dropped by only 5%, followed by the long upswing to 1938.
It was grim, particularly up north, although the 1930s was also a time when the consumer age flowered. Many of those three-bed semis that make up our suburbs were built, UK car output rose fivefold between 1924 and 1937, and electric cookers, vacuum cleaners and washing machines began to come within the reach of ordinary families.
If not depression, then, what about recession? Britain is just approaching the end of a quarter in which GDP will probably have grown by 0.4% or 0.5%, down only a little from the 0.6% recorded in the final three months of last year. This will be the 63rd consecutive quarter of growth.
Growth has slowed but no more than anybody expected. Indeed, the evidence of recent days points to an economy which, if not booming, is defying any crisis.
Retail sales rose by 1% last month, following a 1.1% increase in January, and are up by 5.5% on a year earlier. The figures will have come as news to many retailers, for whom life is a struggle, but suggest the consumer is a long way from collapsing.
Manufacturers are experiencing a healthy rise in orders, particularly in export markets, according to the CBI. Its measure of export orders has just equalled its best reading since 1995 and price pressures are persisting.
Is the job market buckling under the impact of the credit crunch? It has not happened yet, despite some evidence of job losses in financial services. Employment overall rose by 166,000 in the three months to January and unemployment dropped by 32,000. The claimant count continued to fall last month. It is not stretching it too far to say that, if the Bank of England closed its eyes to the credit crisis, it might be thinking of raising interest rates rather than cutting them further.
Everybody thinks employment and unemployment are lagging indicators but the experience of the last recession is instructive. Unemployment was flat for the first half of 1990 and began to fall in the middle of the year, the point when GDP began to decline.
So the economy is holding up, despite weakness in housing and financial services. Will this change? Sir Alan Budd, former government chief economic adviser, likened the experience in 1990 to a cartoon character running off a cliff and suddenly finding there was no means of support. Could history repeat itself?
The three recessions Britain suffered between 1973 and 1992 had a common characteristic. In each case interest rates were raised sharply to curb inflation and, in the case of the 1974-75 and 1990-92 recessions, to end an unsustainable boom. By the time rates were cut, the economy was already in recession and it was too late.
This time interest rates are on the way down at a time when the economy is still growing. But could it be that the squeeze the credit crisis is imposing on the economy will not only make the Bank’s efforts futile but will snuff the life out of the economy? Do we have the private sector – the banks and the financial markets – in effect running monetary policy? It is a point of view, and certainly the pass-through from rate cuts by the Bank is more muted than usual because lenders are rebuilding their profit margins. There still is an effect, however, in the sense that interest rates available to borrowers are lower than they would be in the absence of Bank action. The lower pound, highlighted by exporters as helping them significantly, is also an important transmission mechanism.
In the end, though, modern economies run on credit and if credit suddenly dried up, they would stop growing. Fortunately, and contrary to some of the things you may have read and heard, that is not happening. Credit is certainly tougher to get hold of for some borrowers and will be for some time, but there is still plenty around.
Figures from the Bank last week showed just how much. The broadest measure of lending in the economy, M4 lending, rose £16.4 billion last month, up 12% on a year earlier. Another measure, excluding the effects of securitisations, rose by £19.3 billion for a 13.7% growth rate.
M4 itself, the “broad” money supply, is growing by 12.3%. These are the kind of numbers that have monetarists worrying about boom, not bust. They do not suggest the lending taps have been turned off.
We should not ignore the challenges the economy faces. It would be good to see one group of “investors”, commodity speculators, take a real bath rather than the mild soaking of recent days. A big fall in the oil price would be of considerable help. But this is not the time to dust off the depression and recession primers.
PS: The release of figures showing a rise in inflation and the annual shake-up in the index “shopping basket” – muffins and smoothies in, CD singles and 35mm film out - brought a strange response. I swear I heard a woman on breakfast television say the consumer prices index (CPI) gives iPods as big a weight as food and fuel. Some claim “true” inflation is in double figures.
So let us set the record straight. The CPI, currently rising by 2.5%, has its faults. It does not, however, assume that people buy a new music player or flat-screen television every time they go to the supermarket.
The combined weighting of “audio-visual and related products” in the CPI is tiny, 27 parts in a thousand. The big expenditures that dominate the CPI are the necessities: transport, 152 parts in a thousand, food, drink and tobacco, 151, and household fuel, water and related bills, 115. It incorporates the big increases coming through, such as a 44% rise in fuel oil for central heating and an 18% increase in dairy products.
The CPI is thought to exclude housing but that is not so; rents are included, though not owner-occupied housing. That is included in the retail prices index (RPI), which puts inflation at 4.1%. This, and not double figures, is close to where most people think inflation is - 3.9% according to the Bank’s latest attitudes survey. As for the future, people think inflation will be 3.3% over the next 12 months, halfway between current readings on the two measures.
That seems reasonable, though it is too high for comfort for the Bank. It will not, however, prevent the monetary policy committee, which voted 7-2 to leave Bank rate on hold this month, cutting again soon.
How the new breed of location based mobile services can find your nearest cashpoint, restaurant or wi-fi hotspot
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Are you California dreaming? Explore the wonders of the Golden State. Also enter our fantastic competition
See the best entries in this year's competition
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget


Overseas contacts and local business information
2006
£189,500
NW England
2008/08
£169,950
NW England
2007/57
£35,000
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £82,000 per annum
Birmingham Women's Hospital
Birmingham
To £28k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool/Teeside
£
Up to £66,000 per annum
Hertfordshire County Council
South East
To £38k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool
2 Bathrooms, Balcony and Garden
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Dining, Shopping & Riverside Pk
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property.
© Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
If transport, food and household bills constitute 418 parts in a thousand and they have gone up by between 15-20%, then to make inflation 2-2.5%, something in the (unspecified) remaining 580 parts has to have come down in price considerably. Perhaps David Smith could enlighten us as to what these items are.
I would take David Smith's other reports more seriously if he (and other 'serious' financial journalists) came out of his cocoon in Westminster village and actually shopped for goods that have 'only risen in price by 2.5%' - he would be very unpleasantly surprised.
mnairb, Hove, U.K.
David, we all know that the essential items of food, energy, transportation are increasing in double figures inflation and the CPI is manipulated to keep our wages lower.
If you look at the national statistics website of how CPI is calculated, it wrongly assumes that people will change their buying habits as prices increase. For example it assumes that a tea drinker will switch to buying the alternative beverage of say coffee if tea prices increase by too much in a year, and a year later if the reverse increase to coffee happens that they will switch back to tea, but ignoring the increased starting price level and only measuring any new % increase. A fuller explanation is given at http://www.europac.net/whitepapers/The%20Truth%20About%20CPI.pdf
Also, if RPI inflation is at 4.1% (if not the actual non-manipulated 10%), whilst GDP growth is at lower 1.9%, we as a nation ARE getting much poorer even if we do get a pay rise.
George, London,
David, this is just the beginning of the crisis. In the Wall Street crash of 1929 shares only fell by 10% (comparable to this year), however by 1932 they had fallen by 75%, whilst currently our nation's debt level is much higher versus economic output than it was then. Increasing money supply and lending plus government borrowing may mean no more boom and bust, but it certainly will result in boom, booom, boooom and BOOM!
George, London,