David Smith
2 for 1 tickets to Singin' In The Rain, this coming Monday. Book now
IT tells us something that I have received many more e-mails and letters about sterling’s big fall against the euro than I did a few months ago for a different reason – the $2 pound.
Perhaps we are more European than we think. That is certainly the case in terms of second-home ownership on the Costas and the French countryside. People are also concerned about the impact of sterling’s weakness on import prices. There may be another reason. When sterling is strong the effects are mainly beneficial, certainly for consumers and tourists. Even exporters do not complain too much.
But when sterling is weak it recalls the time when the pound was the tail that wagged the economic-policy dog. There is no question of sterling’s fall against the euro forcing the Bank of England to raise interest rates. There is a risk that sterling weakness, if maintained, might stand in the way of the rate cuts that the economy needs.
For most of last year, sterling was remarkably stable against the euro, at an exchange rate averaging roughly 1.50 euros to the pound. It began to weaken in August, at the point when the credit crisis burst onto the scene.
Sterling stabilised at about €1.45 but embarked on a further big fall from early November. This, as luck would have it, was after Bank governor Mervyn King advised the model Gisele Bundchen, who had complained about dollar weakness, that if she wanted a stable currency for her fees she should look no further than sterling.
To be fair to King, it was his message on interest rates that jinxed the pound, not his modelling advice. This was when the Bank, in its November inflation report, signalled it was switching from wanting to raise interest rates further to wanting to cut.
The European Central Bank, guardian of the euro, had also been widely expected to raise rates further before the end of last year. The ECB, however, has yet to talk of cuts, let alone deliver one as the Bank did last month. Indeed, Jean-Claude Trichet, its French president, has been making hawkish noises about raising rates should there be evidence of inflationary pressure.
It amounts to a loss of sterling’s interest-rate advantage. Add in those dreadful third-quarter current-account figures, loss of confidence in the British banking system as a result of Northern Rock, and the accompanying loss of reputation for the Bank, Treasury and Financial Services Authority and there is a plausible explanation for some of the fall.
The eurozone has not suddenly become an economic success story, however, and will struggle to grow faster than even Britain’s diminished growth rate this year, as began to emerge last week. Tensions within the euro area persist. A change in interest-rate expectations and tough talk from the ECB does not add up to a 14% fall for sterling against the euro over the past year, equivalent to Harold Wilson’s “pound in your pocket” devaluation of 1967.
So something else has been happening, and appears to be directly linked to the credit crisis.
Peter Spencer, in his latest report for the Ernst & Young Item club to be published this week, notes that before August 9, when the crisis broke, there were big short-term capital flows into Britain for a particular reason. Banks and other lenders borrowed internationally, including elsewhere in Europe, to fund some of their UK mortgage lending. These money-market flows helped support the pound.
But when they stopped, as money and credit markets froze, this source of support came to an end. Northern Rock, the credit crisis, the weakness in Britain’s housing market and sterling’s fall are thus directly linked, and by more than just confidence.
This may suggest that, as markets thaw, sterling will regain some of its former composure against the euro. That is what I expect, and there is tentative evidence of it. The big fall, which took the pound down to not much above €1.30, may be drawing to a close, though it is unlikely sterling will recover to anything like its previous highs.
Will this episode have any effect on British attitudes towards joining the euro? On the face of it the euro, having been the ugly duckling of the currency world, has turned into a beautiful swan.
The eurozone has lower interest rates, a harder currency and for now a better-regarded central bank than Britain. These are the conditions that, thanks to Germany, drew a Conservative government under Margaret Thatcher into the arms of the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM).
These days euro membership is so far on the political back burner we do not even bother to ask the question in opinion polls, though it might be worth another outing. When last asked, membership was opposed by two to one. The Treasury vetoed Tony Blair’s last chance to take Britain into the euro in 2003.
Gordon Brown, having presided over two “no” verdicts on entry when chancellor, is not about to warm to the single currency and has plenty of other things on his plate without opening this can of worms. The Tories are ideologically opposed.
So we will watch what happens to sterling and the euro. If the pound falls much further, quite a lot of things could happen. Britain, with a softer currency, could become a less attractive location for migrant workers from Poland and the other EU accession countries.
On the other hand some of the activity that was relocated to other parts of Europe a decade ago, when the pound rose sharply against the euro’s constituent currencies, could find its way back here. With 55% of UK goods exports going to euro countries there could, whisper it quietly, be a revival of British manufacturing.
PS: House prices stopped rising at a point where Halifax calculates private-sector housing is worth £4 trillion, 3.4 times mortgage debt. So the question is asked – do rising house prices do us any good? Would we be better off if they fell?
There are four daft arguments on this. One is that a rise in prices does you no good because until you exit the market you cannot realise gains. But that is true of any asset and plenty of people tap into housing wealth through equity withdrawal.
The second is that because you live in a house it differs from other assets and should not be regarded as wealth. Yes, it is different, and in some respects better. Shares may give you a financial shelter. Housing gives you an actual one.
A third is that the value of housing is always precarious. What if that £4 trillion were to turn into £3 trillion? But house prices are less volatile than shares, and that is also true of any asset.
Finally, are rising prices good for owners but bad for the country? Again this does not stack up. The 70% who are owner-occupiers gain, while the 30% nonowners do not lose – they just don’t gain.
There are better arguments against rising prices; they freeze out potential buyers, steer investment towards “unproductive” housing and reward inertia rather than risk-taking. The tripling of prices over 10 years was certainly too much of a good thing.
The question is the wrong one. The value of housing is boosted by “small island” supply factors but in essence reflects past rises in income and expectations of future growth. Stagnant house prices would tell us the economy had done badly and prospects were poor. Part of the current house-price concern reflects worries about Britain’s prospects.
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
Have you ever dreamed of owning your own racehorse or a beautiful painting?
Enjoy comfort, safety, space and great design. Plus enter our great competition
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Are you California dreaming? Explore the wonders of the Golden State. Also enter our fantastic competition
Do you have what it takes to be a Times photographer?
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
Find out to make the most of your money with our wealth management guides
Need help with your property? We have an entire how to guide - buying, selling, letting, moving, to help you
We are seeking entries for the inaugural Sunday Times Best Green Companies Awards
Enjoy some wonderful inspiring wildlife moments
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget

Overseas contacts and local business information
2007/07
£57,500
South East England
2007/07
£40,995
South East England
2006/06
£41,995
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
£40-55k+benefits+uncapped commission
Morgan Keating
South East
Up to £30,000
GLE
London
£
c£75,000 + executive benefits
Morgan Keating
London and South
Unpaid with travel expenses
Network Rail
Globrix, the property search engine
Visit Times Online Property for homes for sale or rent
Residential development site with planning permission
£1,500,000
Mortgages, bank accounts & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Dinarobin Hotel Golf & Spa 7 nights
From £1830 per person – saving £530.
Walking & multi-activity holidays in Cauterets. Stylish self-catering apartments.
From 350€ for 7 nights.
SAVE 25% on Sandals Luxury Resorts
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property.
© Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Extraordinary comments. I have never seen such a collection of apparently confidently delivered clap-trap from people who clearly have no training. Just about every comment contains some nonsense. Economics isn't like football: you can't just rock up and talk about a game of two halves. And read what Smith is saying furcryingoutloud.
AG, Kingston, UK
A few points on housing. Supply demand fundamentals have provided a lot of the impetus to house price rises over the last decade, as well as low interest rates and full employment. What would happen if a few of these supports were removed?
Firstly, the availability of mortgages credir will be severely reduced over the next year.
Second, the economy is looking a lot less certain, financial services and retail will likely be hit very hard next year. Services throughout the economy are likely to be hit through knock on spending effects by business and the consumer.
Third, imigration is high, so is emigration (but to a lesser extent). If the UK ecomonic environment starts to suffer could this net inflow start to ebb or even go into reverse? Conditions may start to look more favourable elsewhere in Europe or the advantages of being in Britain may start to become less attractive (i.e. greater unemployment) than returning home. The first 2 are short term the last a longer term issue.
Stuart Houghton, Preston, UK
"The value of housing is boosted by âsmall islandâ supply factors but in essence reflects past rises in income and expectations of future growth. Stagnant house prices would tell us the economy had done badly and prospects were poor. Part of the current house-price concern reflects worries about Britainâs prospects."
Just ignore the fact that current house prices are mainly dependent on affordability. So including interest rates, and provision of capital.
If a mortgage broker starts giving out more money, over a longer period, for less deposit, will house prices stay the same?
No, people bid according to their ability to pay. But that is ignored, as prices are deemed to reflect the prospects of Britain. The main thing they reflect this century is low interest rates, and high LTV mortgages over long repayment periods.
Will, London,
Who bailed out UBS?
And what price will they exact for their help.
Derek, Macaé, RJ - Brasil
Rather than reducing interest rates and causing the pound to collapse and real inflation (not the sterilised cpi variety) to rise, why not use tax cuts to put some more money back into people's pockets.
James, NI, UK
The UK economy is structurally flawed and will take decades to put back into a strong export position. The fundamentals are not good and I can see sterling fall back to 1.20 euros to the pound. A new Government and a Marshall plan to cut the public burden may lift our economy in the longer term but I believe we will join the euro before any such recovery would be evident. I and many other ordinary citizens may then be able to freely trade with our European neighbours without being at the mercy of money markets, money changers and speculators.
Steve Marchant, Broadhempston, UK
The amount of all currencies in circulation is increasing as measured in debt. Money is debt remember. But the amount of debt in Euuros has been increasing at a slower rate than that of the Dollar and GBP.
Partly this is due to it being far more difficult to borrow money in Germany than in the UK and USA.
Alan Heaton, Frankfurt, Germany
Who cares about the fall of the Pound? Europeans? I don't think so....The pound's fall is a problem for the UK not for the 15 EU states that share the euro....of course, some goods will be more expensive....but tell me, what does the UK export to the continent?cars? they all belong to foreign companies....high tech? hmmmmm , maybe weetabix , dairy?
The pound has been over valued because of the property rise for so long....owing a house in Britain is an Englishman's nightmare....Britons flock to continental Europe because life is a lot better...with an over valued pound they have had the feeling to buy cheap stuff....now that it's back to normal...hard to cope with. A good rate would be 75/80p to the euro....just like â¬1 = $1.20....but that's theory only......I don't say the situation is better in EU....maybe a litte better, despite lower growth and higher unemeployement......
pascal-Pierre, Dinan, EU (france)
You say in your article..."as money and credit markets froze, this source of support came to an end. Northern Rock, the credit crisis, the weakness in Britainâs housing market and sterlingâs fall are thus directly linked, and by more than just confidence.
This may suggest that, as markets thaw, sterling will regain some of its former composure against the euro. That is what I expect, and there is tentative evidence of it."
I admire your bravado. We'll see.
Halifax reporting a quarterly drop in London house prices of 6.3% at the end of 2007 does not augur well.
harry e, London,
Sterling has fallen against many currencies since last August, and in some cases by more than the 14% fall against the Euro. At its low point last week, Sterling was down around 16% against the Polish Zloty and by 17% against the Japanese Yen.
But banking on the Euro may still end up being misplaced given the tensions in Euroland between rich and poor countries. Really it is just the least worst option at present.
I don't expect the UK to become less attractive for Polish workers just yet: our minimum wage is still more than four times higher than it is in Poland. And any opportunity for increased exporting by British manufacturers is tempered by the huge loss of capacity and skills here in the last ten years.
So all in all, I think Sterling has a way further to fall yet and we will all be squeezed a good deal further before this has all played out.
MarkS, Leeds,
p.s. shares are an investment using surplus funds and are a form of saving for those less risk averse. As you say, a house is somewhere to live BUT
1) / 2) I would rather have a 200k mortgage because house prices are not being driven up by speculators/ VIs, rather than a 300k one...the difference is me having 6k a year more to spend on my family instead of paying it to VIs. I could use equity withdrawal to get the 6k BUT that is then debt I have to pay. Asset prices can fall while debt remains.
3) seems to contradict the other two points...it is not an investment and then it is?
4) the 6k argument above answers this also.
The only thing I do agree with is the point that money is being diverted from productive investment, and it is mentioned as an aside!
Desire to own a house, lack of land, high population growth, low interest rates, robust economy. Dozens of cities/countries used ALL these arguments as to why their housing could never fall. They did.
Raj, London,
Has the time come for us to join the Euro.? We would have more stability and a lower interest rate. The Bank of England have sat on their hands when a 1/2% reduction was called for this month.
The financial melt down in the USA has exposed us to the fact that we can no longer remain independant, especially with a PM who regards himself as a one man team and making wrong decisions every time.
Vernon Cooper, Yeovil, United Kingdom
Why are you so surprised at the fall of sterling? THe ECB got the whole policy right from day one and as such the euro is strong and resilient. THe european banking system is also in better shape than the tapped out uk banks and american banks that lent on the back of the tsunami of the carry trade free cash. The problem is that the tsunami is retreating and the twin debted countries the US and UK are paying the price. prediction for you euro against sterling to parity and against the CHF 1.68. Sterling is finished rather like its over extend economy and it greatly extended credit. IT has no abiity for fiscal stimulus as golden brown has destroyed the UK PLC balance sheet as badly as the UK Banks have damged theirs/. The credit crisis is early doors and UK interest rates will be going up sharply by year end like those in the US to help attract the cash to keep the debtors afloat. Dont worry though China will bail them and the UK out when they will pay 5 pence in the pound for UK PLC
Richard Morrish, neuchatel, switzerland