Anatole Kaletsky: Economic view
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
My last article of every year looks back on the predictions I made in early January to shed some light on the economic and financial events of the previous 12 months. This tends to be a humbling experience, and this year it is even more so than usual.
While the world economy has not done nearly as badly as one might suppose from the financial turmoil that has dominated the headlines, it is still embarrassing to read the opening paragraph of my January outlook: “The period of greatest risk to the world economy is probably over. Interest rates may have a little way to rise in Europe and Japan. But the big rise in American rates, the doubling of oil prices and the inevitable correction in the US housing market have now happened. The biggest risks stem not from economics but from geopolitics. In most of the world, the mid-cycle slowdown is probably almost over and economic strength, rather than weakness, is likely to be the main surprise of 2007.” Only in the eurozone and Japan did I feel that consensus forecasts were a touch overoptimistic and the risks “were mainly on the downside”.
My financial predictions seemed even more egregious, since I ended by suggesting that “the bull markets in shares and property have every reason to continue, at least if we look at economics alone”. From today’s vantage point, in the midst of a banking crisis and housing slump that is spreading from America to Britain and Europe, these comments seem absurdly complacent.
But delving a little deeper into events suggests some justification for my apparent smugness and, more importantly, helps to explain why the past 12 months have proved so confusing to policymakers and so expensive to the banks that placed bets worth hundreds of billions of dollars on faulty financial judgments.
The fact is 2007 was very much a year of two halves. The first half unfolded more or less as I expected: in America, economic growth accelerated strongly after a slow first quarter, while Britain continued to enjoy a boom in economic activity, employment and, above all, housing. Europe and Japan, by contrast, started strongly but had slowed substantially by the middle of the year (see charts). Meanwhile, the emerging economies, especially in Asia, continued to enjoy the best economic conditions in their history. By midsummer the main concern among central bankers and investors was not a possible recession but the risk of global economic overheating. As a result, bond yields in America rose in early June to almost 5.5 per cent – their highest since the start of this global expansion. And analysts were almost unanimous in warning that the 25-year downtrend in long-term interest rates had been broken once and for all.
How different the world looked only a few weeks later, after the seizure suffered by inter-bank lending markets in August and the near-collapse of Northern Rock and a host of mortgage lenders in the US. Much has been written about these events and this is not the place to analyse them again. All I want to do is to put them into perspective by recalling two points that are easy to forget in the present panic. First, that economic growth had a lot of momentum behind it, especially in America and Asia but also in Britain, when the credit crisis struck in August. This is why expectations that the housing crisis would trigger a collapse of US consumption and employment have, so far, proved wide of the mark. Second, and this is easy to lose sight of, shares and house prices have ended this year considerably higher than they began, despite all the horror stories.
In America, the Dow Jones is 7 per cent higher than 12 months ago, having hit a record as recently as October 9. The FTSE 100 is up 5 per cent and Germany’s DAX has gained no less than 23 per cent and is near its all-time high, having fully recovered the losses of July and August. In Asia, stock markets are all far above levels before the credit crisis, with Hong Kong up 40 per cent on the year and Shanghai up 70 per cent. Only in Japan have asset prices substantially fallen, hardly surprising considering the renewed incompetence of the country’s economic and political management since Junichiro Koizumi resigned as prime minister in 2006.
Property markets, too, have faired much better that one might imagine, at least outside America. Last week, Nationwide said its house-price index fell for a second consecutive month in December and most analysts (including me) expect the market to get a lot worse. But it’s the strength, not weakness, of house prices in 2007 that is most remarkable. Nationwide’s figure is 5 per cent higher than a year ago, even after the recent falls. In London, where prices are falling more steeply than in the rest of the country – and are likely to fall faster in the year ahead – the average house price is still about 10 per cent up on the year.
So why do the official statistics differ so totally from the grim picture presented by financial markets and media comments, including mine?
There are three reasons: first, official statistics are, by definition, backward-looking and while it is unlikely that the next few months will see the widely predicted slump into recession, a much weaker period probably does lie ahead, especially outside the US. Second, aggregate statistics give no indication of the huge shifts in activity, employment and profitability between sectors and regions. US housing has suffered a steep decline, but this has been offset by very strong export growth. That, in turn, has reflected a shift in the world economy towards emerging markets, which now contribute almost 30 per cent of economic activity and much more to growth. Third, the haemorrhage suffered by the financial system in the mortgage bubble has so far done very little damage to the real economy of jobs, consumption and investment. But the banks cannot continue to lose at the rate they have since August without eventually weakening economic activity around the world.
The key question for the year ahead, therefore, is whether the banking crisis is almost over or whether investors and governments will allow the spiral of losses to accelerate until it drags the entire world economy into some kind of a black hole. My views, for what they are worth, about this and the other risks to the global economic outlook will appear here on January 14.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
One keeps reading about a housing slowdown, even a crisis, in the States. Perhaps there's one, but certainly there's a housing boom here near Colorado Springs, Colorado. It's a boom I wish would slow, because it threatens my privacy, my house on a wooded 5 acre track north of town. And the roads have become uncomfortably crowded for a country driver such as I.
Dave Livingston, El Paso County, Colorado, USA
Anatole,
I came from Megeve yesterday.I did not notice any crisis. I witnessed prosperity. I did not witness a " Banking Crisis" in Tel Aviv, Geneva, Zurich, Paris, Prague, Zagreb,Moscow, or Helsinki.
Do you mean to say that British Banks losing their profits over silly loans to five-times-overpriced-apartments in London is equal to a " World Crisis " ? As an Economist myself, I usually refrain from using poetry. Its not our specialization. Happy New Year
Shimon, Geneva, Switzerland
Now that 2007 is over, and you were completely, utterly, tragically, not quite criminally, WRONG, like all other economists all the time, why not get smashed tonight and resolve get a JOB in 2008?
Tim, Winnipeg, Canada
A simple question: How can the banks be so clever with their risk management 'vehicles', that they don't even know what their debts are? Such mathematical sophistication sounds more like simple arithmetical folly. If this is obvious now, why was it not obvious to all (including financial journalists) from the start?
Alex, Bristol,
The problems in the banking sector are a very good reflection of our own economy and is the result of fueling growth on the back of unsupported debt and all at record levels. A massive correction is, in my opinion, the only outcome. There are many reasons behind the currant situation and are in the main based on foolish assumptions that you can go on forever growing economically on ever increasing debt. Gordon Brown is now outed as nothing more than a charlatan and his economic competence is nothing but a myth. He will not escape his comeuppance as the year ahead unfolds.
These things I know.
D Case, Newquay,
Are you serious? Property in London about to 'fall faster in the year ahead'. Why do even seasoned economists lose sight of the fact that the London property market is supported by the cast iron laws of supply and demand? Supply in any area which can truly be called 'London' (as opposed to areas within ONLY one hour commuting distance [also known as 'extra day a week travelling]) will not begin to match increasing demand in the lifetime of any living adult. Why don't you commentators just own up? If you are not NOW on the London property ladder, you are pretty well stuck in rented property for the rest of your life.
david jones, london,
It's not the Governments job to bail out Bankers who have made bad decisions, that's the publics' job, after all we are the ones who will have to pay for this mess, Won't we?
Graham Palfrey, Littlehampton,
It's not the Governments job to bail out Bankers who have made bad decisions, that's the publics' job, after all we are the ones who will have to pay for this mess, Won't we?
Graham Palfrey, Littlehampton,
I like to read his column once in a while, but I remember with regret following his advice one year in the 90s when he strongly suggested investing in Japanese shares.
I note also that the best predictor of future inflation is predicting the previous year to repeat itself.
Bill Haynes, Lynchburg, Virginia
Anatole, we must all agree that we are facing an economic 'black hole'. I do not have your knowledge of ewconomics but from a lay perspective see things very simply - we Anglo Saxon economies have been living on other peoples credit for too long. We now need to pay our way in the world or at very least slow down consumption. Thee is no painless way out as both private and public expenditure is reduced.
My main concern is for the political and social fallout over the coming year. A year of crises:-
Sterling crises
Public funding crises
Winter of discontent with public service strikes
Social crises with street riots
Government confidence crises
We need an all party united approach with MPs (& economists?) leading by example and taking a pay cut!
Steve Marchant, Torquay, UK
Yes, I'd forgotten that Anatole made that Golden Age prediction. He does listen too much to his master's voice.
John Walter, Bonn, Germany
The delay you observe is to allow all the banks, financial houses and their bought politicos, time to clean out their accounts and run away with as much money as they can.
No one has any idea how to stem the tide of this tsunami.
Remember the soverign people were content to work the jobs they were 'given' by the phony economy and make believe everything was OK. Well now they have no freedom, no money and most of all no job.
A Adams, Washington, USA
I'm still waiting for your greatest prediction to come true - namely the Euro will melt like Camembert cheese. When's that going to happen? Anatole should indeed be embarrassed every time he ditches common sense and writes the party line, as he did at the start of 2007.
John Walter, Bonn, Germany
The delay you observe is to allow all the banks, financial houses and their bought politicos, time to clean out their accounts and run away with as much money as they can.
No one has any idea how to stem the tide of this tsunami.
Remember the soverign people were content to work the jobs they were 'given' by the phony economy and make believe everything was OK. Well now they have no freedom, no money and most of all no job.
A Adams, Washington, USA
Property had precious little chance of REAL growth in 2007 and actually you had to look no further than price to net disposable income to figure that one out nationally. London was always going to be 'different' to the braod picture because it is so heavily influenced by the 'city' which was still floating high on retrospective performance.
By REAL growth net it down to account for loss of purchasing power this year. For that I'd take the RPI as the closest measure although I suspect it's still short measuring for the average Joe who actually has equity accumulated in property.
To answer your question about whether the banking 'crisis' is over you don't need to look any further than to ask do you think the property market has squeezed out it's excesses yet? Hardly begun ,so the finance sector have some hard times to come for the next two years at least.
SC, PRESTON, LANCS
Mr.Kaletsky is as good as it gets, in macro forecasting.No body, not even the best good and the great get things right 100% of the time..up to you to filter with your own opinion,analysis.
Even more remarkable is that Mr.Kaletsky combines this with superb editorial skills.
JeremyR, London,
Anatole,
You saved me in October 1987 and you haven't been bad since, except for your support of Labor
Predictions are a dangerous business..
All the best in 2008
Pauli, London,
Artzher,
I disagree with you. I think Dr. Kaletsky is a very good economist but not so good an analyst of trendlines!
I believe his article sometime back titled 'the beginning of the end for New Labour' did not sufficiently make allowances for Brown's resilience and staying power. After all he saw off about 5/6 shadow chancellors and a determined Prime Minister.
Time will tell!
LAKSHMAN PARDHANANI, Goa, India
Dr Kaletsky is a good analyst of trendlines, but a very poor economist. I don't believe him since the day of Iraq invasion when he predicted a global Golden Age to come as a result of inevitable sharp oil prices dropdown ....
Artzher, Exeter, UK